Both courses/companies have been great for me though as a non-programmer. I think these companies and others like them have bright futures.
That's not to say Codecademy hasn't been useful. If anything, it was the service that helped me get a grasp of javascript, which I'm now implementing in my personal projects. But I wish there was more.
I would really love to see how the drop out rates are. At one point it seemed to me the only ones left are those who already are decent programmers and just love to discuss semantics in the forum sections. I had convinced three friends of mine to start with it as well and over time each single one dropped out.
I should say that the addition of the Q and A forums was a very good change. I have no doubt you'll introduce many more as you learn what works and what doesn't.
Another useful change that I remember from the final weeks was adding a review unit at the start of each lesson - before that I often found myself forgetting syntax.
It was fun and interesting for a while. But the instructions began to get cumbersome. You had to read 3-4 paragraphs just to learn that they wanted you to write a simple, one line loop.
I spent more time reading instructions than thinking about or writing code.
I was using K & R at the same time, and the contrast was instructive. In K & R you're given a concise description of a feature, and then a short exercise that forces you to think about how to use it.
In the final few weeks, my only motivation to keep going with Codecademy was the thought that "at least I'll have these badges that show what I know". That was a pretty big warning sign.
I stopped when I realized I wasn't even learning the concepts in the lessons. There simply wasn't enough coding practice for them to stick.
I haven't been there for a few weeks, so perhaps things have gotten better. But from what I saw, they needed to work on cutting out the cruft in their instructions. Pedagogy is difficult.