Re:What Is a Flop?
by fluoridation on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @06:39AM
(#37403362)
>In other words, if a CPU runs at 1 MHz and has two units but where only one can run `fmul`, should you count the CPU as having one or two MFLOPS?
I don't think there's enough information to answer that question. For starters, even if the CPU was issued a long sequence of nothing but additions, it's possible that it might spend some fraction of that million cycles waiting on memory.
I don't think FLOPS are counted from first principles, I think they're measured empirically using benchmarks. It's possible one benchmark will yield 1.25 MFLOPS and another 1.8 MFLOPS. Split the difference and call it a day.
A modern processor is typically superscalar, with multiple individually pipelined floating point units that can each be issued one instruction per cycle: regardless of whether that is a `fmadd`, a `fadd or something else.
If you'd issue a `fmadd` to a unit, then you are prevented from issuing a `fadd` to it in that same cycle, and vice versa. That's one op, not two.
However, floating point units are sometimes heterogeneous. I think the question should be, rather: should you count the throughput of any ops, or of arbitrary ops. In other words, if a CPU runs at 1 MHz and has two units but where only one can run `fmul`, should you count the CPU as having one or two MFLOPS?