Re:Hot Chips 2023: SiFive’s P870 Takes RISC-V Further
by brucehoult on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @09:19PM
(#37400213)
Intel walked away? It was my impression the Intel offer was unsolicited and it was SiFive who said "nah, not interested".
It's certainly not impossible, but it seems a tough row to hoe.
But the cool part of this is that the ISA and many supporting packages (rocket, boom, etc.) are "open" and "free as in beer." Even if SiFive did fail, an IP investment in RISC-V would not necessarily have been a bad move. Which is why I said I'm fairly bullish on RISC-V (cause even if SiFive fails, customers existing investment in the ISA is not lost) but bearish on SiFive (because I fear their existing valuation may be too inflated.)
I'm not trying to tell anyone their SiFive baby is ugly. I'm not saying designing a RISC-V solution is a bad move. I'm just saying from my perspective, with incomplete information about what's going on inside SiFive, it looks like they have a difficult road ahead. I would POSITIVELY WELCOME any information regarding reference customers or catalog parts which might imply there's a large customer who's signed on the dotted line to pay SiFive a royalty for using their designs.
Full disclosure: I own no SIFIVE stock (or options) nor do I own stock in any company that competes in the RISC-V design space (Esperanto, Andes, Sandisk/WD, etc.) I still have stock in TXN though, but I haven't heard that they're deep in RISC-V. I am a former employee of SiFive, but was not employed in a management position; don't take my comments as being based on "inside information."