Re:Hot Chips 2023: SiFive’s P870 Takes RISC-V Further
by eigenform on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @01:31PM
(#37395066)
I can totally understand it being too "heavy-handed" a solution for tons of cases, definitely! Thanks for sharing :)
Re:Hot Chips 2023: SiFive’s P870 Takes RISC-V Further
by taway32r41 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @02:05AM
(#37415288)
> SiFive was working on CoC (theorum prover) extensions to validate designs using formal methods. THAT sounds fascinating, but I'm not sure how they would monetize it.
Synopsys seems to think it's a decent business to be in. :)
https://www.synopsys.com/verification/static-and-formal-veri...
But yes... this led us to a working style where we tried very hard to avoid having to use rocket or boom generators. I didn't want to be in the business of maintaining RISC-V Verilog tools. At around the same time we realized RISC-V was overkill and built a very poorly designed Lisp DSL which output Verilog for a dog-simple 6-bit controller. Not an ideal solution to be sure, but it worked better for us than spending a couple years learning Rocket/Scala/Chisel.
Nick Tredennick (who I believe was the main designer of the 68k) has a quote in his book "Logic Design: The Flowchart Method":
I don't want to say Rocket / Chisel / Firrtl is bad, but it always seemed to be more in support of a "process focused" methodology than the "solution oriented" focus I'm used to. If it works for you, I'm absolutely not going to tell you it's a bad idea to use it. It's just too much overhead for the small projects I work on.That being said... SiFive was working on CoC (theorum prover) extensions to validate designs using formal methods. THAT sounds fascinating, but I'm not sure how they would monetize it.
[Edit: To recap, I don't have a problem with Rocket / Chisel / Firrtl per se, but they operate at a level I'm uncomfortable with and seem to be less stable than I would prefer. I completely understand this is not the case for many other people.]