Re:Poll: How do you feel about making HN invite only?
by luckystrike on Sunday November 23, 2008 @02:56PM
(#373991)
I agree with the suggestion that submissions should be disallowed until one reaches a specific karma value. It is becoming incredibly harder now to up-vote the right kind of posts from the 'new' section. A smaller sample space would be helpful in getting mostly the right content on the front page.
Writing thoughtful comments (even if they are disagreements) to get the desired karma for submissions is as good as a pseudo-invite.
The one tricky part would be whether to allow 'Ask HN' posts or not from new accounts that haven't reached the specific karma level yet. I think they should be allowed, as sometimes one needs to create a temp account, to get some useful feedback/suggestions for some situations where one cannot disclose the identity very obviously.
Re:Poll: How do you feel about making HN invite only?
by dejb on Sunday November 23, 2008 @07:12PM
(#374247)
Possibly a new user would be allowed to submit but their vote would count for nothing. Only if a established users voted for it would it stand a chance if making the front page. Some people are bound to be better article finders than commentors and their input could be valuable.
I don't think invite-only is a good thing. It probably would have prevented me from ever being here.