Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function?
by jrockway on Sunday November 23, 2008 @02:18PM
(#373943)
Then again, I don't see what the utility of decaying karma is personally. It smacks of "what have you done for me lately". I think it's OK to respect people for past glories.
Incidentally, this is one of the reasons why I don't participate on Perlmonks. There are a lot of people there that have "been around forever" and answer questions as though it's 1999. I really enjoy reading the "don't use Moose, it's bloat" threads from people I've never heard of.
Anyway, karma decay would be good for Perlmonks, IMHO.
Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function?
by jbert on Sunday November 23, 2008 @04:39PM
(#374096)
Interesting. Perhaps that's perl's main problem. Ruby (or python) snatched up that generation of hackers since they could make more of a splash. Someone commented on reddit a few weeks back "perl used to have a really cool culture"
OK - I can now see a benefit of favouring recent contributors. It helps stop ossificiation.
Like money which will decay with inflation, or perhaps the regard of people who will be dust in a few decades?
> If karma is constantly going down anyway it will confuse the issue
If that's a problem, the site can provide the 1st derivative (ignoring decay). A bit like music charts ("at number 10, up 5, it's...").
Some sites (perlmonks) already give you an xp (karma) delta whenever you reload the page. A last 24-hours delta would be more useful (again ignoring decay).
Then again, I don't see what the utility of decaying karma is personally. It smacks of "what have you done for me lately". I think it's OK to respect people for past glories.