News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function? by PieSquared on Sunday November 23, 2008 @11:50AM (#373800)
I think a good idea would be to treat karma the same way that tennis rankings are counted: Only the past 52 weeks are counted. So if you gain 1000 karma in a year, then don't participate, your karma will be 0.

That will encourage continual good behavior.

Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function? by mechanical_fish on Sunday November 23, 2008 @12:04PM (#373813)
I think rankings in other sports might be more fun if they worked more like HN rankings. Baseball fans do a lot of that. It's kind of what baseball statistics are all about: The player in front of you is not just competing with himself, and the other players on the field, and the other players in the league. In a sense, he's competing with Lou Gehrig.

Of course, the reason to avoid putting dead players in the rankings is that the people who prefer watching competitions between living players -- i.e. the majority of fans -- don't want the dead ones cluttering up their leaderboard. But this is the web, not TV, so the solution is simple: Multiple leaderboards. Create a version of the HN leaderboard that only counts the past 52 weeks. Put it up at some URL or other. Then people can decide to use the alternative leaderboard if they want.

Heck, if we want, we can allow every reader to create his or her own leaderboard algorithm. Then we can have big chair-throwing debates about which leaderboard best represents the True State of Play on HN. That is exactly how the world of baseball statistics works. ;)

Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function? by gambling8nt on Sunday November 23, 2008 @05:02PM (#374125)
I don't think we actually want to have chair-throwing debates over who the karma leaders are...while the leaderboard is a slight concession in the general direction of caring about karma, this site has always been set-up to stress the content of a comment over the nature of the author precisely because the accumulation of karma should be mostly irrelevant. Every comment that is posted about karma or some other meta-aspect of the community (including this one) is another comment that isn't actually content itself, and we should be trying to minimize such things when it is possible to do so.
Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function? by Prrometheus on Sunday November 23, 2008 @12:33PM (#373836)
You assume that karma encourages good behavior. If that were the case, then I think this would be a good idea.
Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function? by sh1mmer on Sunday November 23, 2008 @02:44PM (#373976)
I couldn't agree more. Karma encourages karma getting behavior. Sometimes that overlaps with good.
Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function? by PieSquared on Sunday November 23, 2008 @04:10PM (#374069)
Agreed. Karma might not be the best system for encouraging good behavior... But does anyone have any other ideas?

It's also slightly more difficult because what constitutes good behavior isn't always black and white and isn't even always agreed upon.

Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function? by run4yourlives on Sunday November 23, 2008 @02:50PM (#373984)
Karma ensures popular behaviour, not "good".

If that's what you're gunning for, it's a great idea. What's popular is only dependent on your users and their tastes, and this can change over time.

Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function? by sh1mmer on Sunday November 23, 2008 @02:47PM (#373980)
That encourages lock-in. What if my wife had a baby and I went offline for a year because I didn't have time. Would that make my opinions suddenly invalid?

Tennis rankings are based on physical form. Physical form is something much more likely to change year to year than intellectual form.

Someone might be out of date with the latest topics, consensus from the community, etc but it doesn't imply their thinking apparatus or world view has dramatically altered.

Re:Ask HN: Do social sites with karma need a decay function? by lehmannro on Monday November 24, 2008 @01:14AM (#374517)
But then again karma is no indicator for intellect or sanity, is it?