News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Docker Is Four Things by amluto on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:25AM (#37361798)
On the one hand, that’s really cool. On the other hand, I just leaned (from that article!) that the Dockerfile “syntax” is actually a reference to a Docker container. It’s turtles all the way down!

Seriously, though:

> The external files are downloaded in separate alpine images, and then use the copy helper to move them into the final image. It uses a small script to verify the checksums of the downloaded binaries s = s.Run(shf("echo \"%s %s\" | sha256sum -c -", e.Sha256, downloadDst)).Root(). If the checksum does not match, the command fails, and the image build stops.

Having any nontrivial build operation being an invocation of an entire Docker container seems like a terrible design. Docker is cool, but actual host-native Linux userspace images are a really rather nastily complicated way to express computation. What’s wrong with Lua or JavaScript or WASM or quake-c or Java or Lisp or any other sandboxable way to express computation that is actually intended for this sort of application? (All of the above, unlike Docker, can actually represent a computation such that a defined runtime can run it portably.

Docker images, being the sort of turtle that are not amenable to a clean build process, don’t seem like a good thing to try to fix by turtles-all-the-way-downing them.

There are no comments on this comment yet.