News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by ndsipa_pomu on Friday September 01, 2023 @08:16AM (#37349803)
Stopping cars from parking all over bike lanes is definitely important. However, broken glass on bike lanes is common as debris tends to migrate or be swept to the side of the road which is usually where the bike lanes are. Also, wet, decomposing leaves can be a major slip hazard for cyclists.

Snow and ice are another reason to sweep bike lanes and it's interesting that in some active-travel friendly countries in the EU, they prioritise clearing the bike lanes first - presumably the theory is that bike lanes can transport a far greater number of people and cars don't usually have a problem with falling over when the road is slippery.

Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by Fradow on Friday September 01, 2023 @10:10AM (#37351073)
There is a definitive solution to debris on bike lanes though: puncture-resistant tires. Sure, they are not cheap, at around 100€ for both (which is as much as a whole cheap bike), but they do not puncture. In years of having puncture-resistant tires, I have not had a flat tires, and I commute by bike daily in a busy city. Now I don't even bother avoiding glass even if I see it in advance.

Snow, ice and wet leaves are definitely concerns though. If there is a hint of snow/ice, I will not ride my bike, as bike lanes aren't plowed/salted and I don't have snow tires (not enough days of freezing temperature here to make it worth it). It's the only weather reason to not take my bike actually.

Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by ndsipa_pomu on Friday September 01, 2023 @10:54AM (#37351578)
I think you're approaching the issue from the wrong direction.

Broken glass is not a desirable feature of any part of the road, bike lanes or pavements (sidewalks). Puncture proof tyres won't help if someone loses their balance and gets a face full of broken glass.

The answer is to remove broken glass and other detritus. This is surely just a basic function of society.

Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by Angostura on Friday September 01, 2023 @11:29AM (#37352070)
> There is a definitive solution to debris on bike lanes though: puncture-resistant tires.

Fantastic - no need to sweep anywhere at all now. We just wear thick boots and make sure cars have thick tyres

Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by loeg on Friday September 01, 2023 @11:38AM (#37352192)
Puncture-resistant tires have awful ride quality; this is not a general solution to the problem of debris.
Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by blacksmith_tb on Friday September 01, 2023 @11:44AM (#37352269)
I will let you enjoy the hand-sewn joy and keep commuting on my kevlar-belted Contis, I think. Having to replace a tube (I don't even both to patch any more) in near-freezing rain is very low on my list of favorite activities.
Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by loeg on Friday September 01, 2023 @12:41PM (#37353118)
No one wants flats in freezing rain. That’s why we’re advocating for sweeping lanes of broken glass and other debris.
Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by blacksmith_tb on Friday September 01, 2023 @05:06PM (#37356183)
Which I am also all in favor of, but I think I will stay on kevlar even if that day comes, sort of the cycling equivalent of 'trust, but verify'.
Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by ndsipa_pomu on Friday September 01, 2023 @12:06PM (#37352581)
Whilst I agree with it not being the way to deal with debris, tubeless tyres have great ride quality and can shrug off most punctures. Their only downsides are excessive cost, expertise needed to install/change them and occasionally getting squirted with sealant if a hole doesn't seal immediately.
Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by loeg on Friday September 01, 2023 @12:34PM (#37353025)
Tubeless tires and the kind of stiff, slippery, puncture resistant tires GP is talking about (Gatorskins or Marathons) are somewhat orthogonal. Tubeless certainly helps! I ride tubeless Conti GP5000s (which have fantastic ride quality) personally, but they would not work well if I was constantly riding in glass. (I also regularly go thousands of miles without flatting, but that is in large part because I don’t have to ride through broken glass.)
Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by ndsipa_pomu on Friday September 01, 2023 @12:50PM (#37353243)
GP5000s for the win!

I doubt any pneumatic tyre would be suitable for constantly riding over broken glass. Solid tyres, however would last a while until they got completely shredded, but the ride quality of solid tyres is dismal. The problem is that the shock of a bump isn't distributed around the tyre as it would be with air, but instead stays in one place. That then requires a stiffer material to be used so that you don't put too many dings in your rim which makes the ride quality (and speed) worse. Riding on solid tyres really sucks the fun out of cycling.

Re:Bike Lane Sweepers (2021) by breischl on Friday September 01, 2023 @10:11AM (#37351081)
As a cyclist that sounds great, but don't the plows for the roadway then push snow back onto the bike lanes? That would happen with the designs I'm familiar with but maybe they have a different layout or something.