Re:The low, low cost of (committing) cybercrime
by anonym29 on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:07PM
(#37345960)
Corporate red teamer here.
> A bigger problem for me personally is the high cost of reducing developer productivity and increasing operational risk just for the sake of cyberponies trying to defend their job.
Could you please elaborate further on this? When you talk about reduced developer productivity, are you referring to proper DMARC implementations, doing security "correctly" more broadly, the impact of compromises, or what?
> Also I am not so sure the cost is that low. Well for phishing attacks maybe, but what is the return here??
Credentials, and therefore access. You may have nothing valuable in your mailbox at any given point in time, but how often can you honestly say you routinely review forwarding addresses to make sure incoming email isn't compromised? With email being widely used as a password reset mechanism, that's basically giving the adversary the "keys to the kingdom" regarding your online accounts if they can get in and add a forwarding rule without you noticing it.
> Many skilled people had been caught doing 'cybercrime'.
I'd contest this. The people who get caught only get caught because they make operational mistakes - at least in the US, the entire criminal justice system is more or less built around tracing the operational mistakes of criminals. The truly skilled adversaries don't get caught. There are rarely news articles about them. This is kind of like reverse survivorship bias.
> I just thin k if you compare this to e.g. tax-fraud then I would expect the risk/reward to be much higher than doing phishing attacks.
The risk with tax fraud is that there's a paper trail to a KYC'd account sooner or later... at least until the Treasury starts giving refunds in cryptocurrency (i.e. never). No such risk with a great deal of hacking-related crimes.
> A bigger problem for me personally is the high cost of reducing developer productivity and increasing operational risk just for the sake of cyberponies trying to defend their job.
Could you please elaborate further on this? When you talk about reduced developer productivity, are you referring to proper DMARC implementations, doing security "correctly" more broadly, the impact of compromises, or what?
> Also I am not so sure the cost is that low. Well for phishing attacks maybe, but what is the return here??
Credentials, and therefore access. You may have nothing valuable in your mailbox at any given point in time, but how often can you honestly say you routinely review forwarding addresses to make sure incoming email isn't compromised? With email being widely used as a password reset mechanism, that's basically giving the adversary the "keys to the kingdom" regarding your online accounts if they can get in and add a forwarding rule without you noticing it.
> Many skilled people had been caught doing 'cybercrime'.
I'd contest this. The people who get caught only get caught because they make operational mistakes - at least in the US, the entire criminal justice system is more or less built around tracing the operational mistakes of criminals. The truly skilled adversaries don't get caught. There are rarely news articles about them. This is kind of like reverse survivorship bias.
> I just thin k if you compare this to e.g. tax-fraud then I would expect the risk/reward to be much higher than doing phishing attacks.
The risk with tax fraud is that there's a paper trail to a KYC'd account sooner or later... at least until the Treasury starts giving refunds in cryptocurrency (i.e. never). No such risk with a great deal of hacking-related crimes.