News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by runnerup on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @11:50PM (#37332239)
> SV does reject con artists

The incredible amount of money Andreesen Horowitz poured into so many different crypto scams contradicts this. Not to mention the incredible amount of terrible companies which had business plans that were prima facie ridiculous.

Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by MichaelZuo on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:32AM (#37332848)
Did you really expect a 100% perfect rate? i.e. infallibility?

No real system can accomplish that, even 99.9% is already a very high bar.

Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by reaperman on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:44AM (#37332919)
A16Z has a portfolio size of $35 billion and invested nearly $8 billion in pure cryptocurrency schemes (probably quite a bit more additional investment through some of their funds which aren't exclusively crypto plays). We're not talking "99.9% avoidance of obvious scams" or any other tiny fraction.

Their flagship crypto fund was down 40% in 2022. Even if it returned profits to shareholders since its seed investments in 2009, it did so at the expense of people who bought in later, like all crypto wins. They didn't "create value" they, at best, extracted value from crypto scams. And at this point it's not even clear to me how the fund is performing overall.

Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by MichaelZuo on Thursday August 31, 2023 @09:31AM (#37336877)
Yes but we're talking about SV as a whole, not a specific firm? If we assume a quarter of a16z's crypto investments will turn out to be actual frauds, which is a big assumption, that's only a small bit of all the money flowing through SV.

And plus I think even a 98% success rate of avoiding scams is already pretty noteworthy, like I said even 99.9% is a very high bar.

Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by runnerup on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:30PM (#37339822)
Where did you get 98% from?
Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by MichaelZuo on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:00PM (#37340315)
It's my personal bar for someone/some group to be considered honest. I'm not sure what 'reaperman's threshold is but I doubt it's literally 100% or even 99.9%.
Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by runnerup on Thursday August 31, 2023 @01:15PM (#37340550)
So you’re asserting that it’s your belief that less than 2% of Silicon Valley VC money is invested in scams or invested to perpetuate a scam?

Besides A16Z, what are the other investment firms that you feel comprises the core of Silicon Valley VC culture?

Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by MichaelZuo on Thursday August 31, 2023 @05:33PM (#37343964)
No not really? Why would I be asserting that to you or anyone else?

Obviously I don't have access to the detailed financial records of every major player in SV, nor likely does anyone else on HN.

Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by runnerup on Thursday August 31, 2023 @07:36PM (#37344953)
The “major players” post the vast majority of their investments because they’re advertising their funds to potential limited partners. It also publicly signaling the strength of the companies they invest in which improves their outcomes through ease of negotiating future business agreements with potential customers and partners.

So it’s definitely possible to establish an approximate upper and lower bound, and it’s way above your 2% limit.

You’d either have to accept that SV does, in fact, deal heavily in scams, or post-facto adjust your tolerance limit to set the bar lower.

Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by MichaelZuo on Friday September 01, 2023 @12:48AM (#37346906)
What are you talking about? If you somehow know better then link or reference the sources.
Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by runnerup on Friday September 01, 2023 @05:24AM (#37348540)
Again: which VC’s do you consider the core of Silicon Valley business culture?

I did A16Z already. This only involves a very easy google search, and maybe throw in some crunchbase searches. It’s an absolutely trivial task and I’d expect you to try doing this exercise on at least one other VC that you’re interested in.

I could do an exhaustive analysis of public data, but that would be more of a blog post than a discussion comment. I expect you to put in a minimum amount of effort towards fact-checking if you want people to take your strong opinions seriously.

Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by MichaelZuo on Friday September 01, 2023 @09:14AM (#37350394)
So if your not going to actually cite enough sources for your claims to be credible, why would anyone take your opinion seriously either?
Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by runnerup on Friday September 01, 2023 @11:52AM (#37352366)
For the third time: which VC’s do you consider the core of Silicon Valley business culture?

I need you to answer this question so that when I do the analysis I’m not wasting time analyzing investment firms that you don’t think represent Silicon Valley.

I’ll write the blog post for you. But not if you won’t participate in this discussion with a bare minimum of contributing effort. Otherwise it’s purely a one-way discussion, where I do all the work and you just say “no no no”. But I haven’t gotten a single constructive iota from you in this entire discussion. You’ve put in zero effort at all.

Re:You Are Not the Man in the Arena by MichaelZuo on Sunday September 03, 2023 @07:50PM (#37375771)
It seems your confused 'runnerup', your behaving as if I had initially responded to your comment, when in fact it's the opposite, even more so as you started asking strangely combative questions under a response I made for 'reaperman'.

Usual HN custom is to answer one question after the other user answers one, or two for two, etc., not to ignore them and immediately demand answers to subsequent questions. And I had already answered two without even getting an answer to:

>Why would I be asserting that to you or anyone else?