News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A serious case for dynamic scoring (immigration) by asu_thomas on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @07:34PM (#37330510)
If the Indian professionals are such a blessing for American workers, why have they left Indian workers out to dry? India has even greater wealth inequality than the US.

> You have to be a hardcore racist and/or an idiot to argue with data that overwhelming.

This is quite rich coming from someone trying to argue that Indians have some kind of inborn "job creator" qualities, knowing perfectly well that they're describing the privileged beneficiaries of the brutally exploitative Indian caste system.

If you want working Americans to welcome you, presuming we're racist for disagreeing is the wrong way to begin.

Re:A serious case for dynamic scoring (immigration) by soligern on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:18PM (#37331320)
I didn’t really mention any “inherent” qualities. Just pointed out facts that buttress an argument to increase immigration. The right wing loves to point out cultural discrepancies in minority populations they vilify but apparently pointing out effective culture is anathema.

I’m American. India is a country that has been growing at an average rate of 7% for more than two decades and has plenty of billion dollar unicorns and a strong culture of entrepreneurship. It’s the 3rd largest economy in the world by PPP, it just takes a couple of decades to recover from two centuries of outright looting.

Re:A serious case for dynamic scoring (immigration) by asu_thomas on Thursday August 31, 2023 @08:24AM (#37336073)
> The right wing loves to point out cultural discrepancies in minority populations they vilify but apparently pointing out effective culture is anathema.

It's not "effective culture". It's effective wealth and everybody knows it. Indian-American migrants are almost all Brahmin elite who amassed their riches from exploiting the oppressed Indian working class. There is absolutely nothing impressive about that. It's hideous.

> India is a country that has been growing at an average rate of 7% for more than two decades

Literally who cares? Why should any Indian or American worker give a single shit about this? Why would this make American workers want more Indian migrants moving to America? Because India's elite have a lot of money and oppressed masses? You have no point to make as far as I can tell.

> and has plenty of billion dollar unicorns and a strong culture of entrepreneurship

Again who cares? Not me.

Re:A serious case for dynamic scoring (immigration) by alsodumb on Thursday August 31, 2023 @10:09AM (#37337369)
You seem to be acting with a malicious intent here, trying to attribute the success of Indian immigrants to them exploiting others in India?

In your flagged comment, you mention "migrants are almost all Brahmin elite who amassed their riches thanks to the deeply exploitative Indian caste system". By your logic, the migrants path would've been a EB-5 investor visa.

Yet, if you look at most successful indian immigrants, they usually work their way up to top grad schools in the US, worked their way up in companies, or at some point depart the company to start their our company, and in almost all cases with American capital and investment.

Re:A serious case for dynamic scoring (immigration) by asu_thomas on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:08PM (#37339445)
Wrong. You are the one making strange assumptions.

For one, your narrative fails to explain why such a drastically disproportionate number of Indian migrants are from upper castes. This is difficult to overstate since nearly all Indian-American migrants are from upper castes that collectively make up only a few percentage points of the total population of India. If you can't explain this, you're obviously missing something or choosing to ignore it.

A college-aged upper class Indian whose parents are alive would have significant wealth and mobility without having investment funds, obviously. As such, their expected path would be through attending American colleges and work visas.

The cost of migrating from India to the US is tremendous. In addition to the more obvious tuition costs and practical costs of uncertainty/risk, the corrupt market for work visas is favored by upper class Indians specifically because it allows them to leverage their family's wealth in what is effectively a black market for access to US employers interested in hiring Indian migrants, and in-turn access to work visas.

Re:A serious case for dynamic scoring (immigration) by asu_thomas on Thursday August 31, 2023 @03:54PM (#37342831)
> You seem to be acting with a malicious intent here

Excuse me? I am acting with an intent of honesty. If you consider honesty malicious, then sure, but that is another point we disagree on.

With all due respect, you seem to be acting with the intent of dishonesty.