Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by meow on Tuesday March 20, 2012 @04:35PM
(#3731399)
I really like the idea. My only nitpick is that these days most projects seem to be ending up as jQuery plugins even when they don't really use much of its functionality. I think a standalone version would save a bit of effort for some of us bound to other frameworks (or not using any framework).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by lukeschlather on Tuesday March 20, 2012 @11:49PM
(#3733009)
I'm not going to lose sleep over adding a JQuery dependency. The fact is it gets you code that targets 95% of browsers with no hacks. I don't want to code explicitly for IE6-8, and JQuery gets me a lot of functionality on those browsers for free. Sure, there may be other frameworks, and sure, JQuery has its faults, and sure, a framework seems like overkill. But I feel a lot more sure about the functionality of my code when I'm relying on a broadly tested cross-browser suite.
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by jarek on Tuesday March 20, 2012 @11:57PM
(#3733035)
An option would be nice for those who did decide, for whatever reason, to not use jquery.
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by MicahWedemeyer on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @07:11AM
(#3733835)
The source is available and the license allows for derivatives. Would you be interested in forking the code and putting together a plain-javascript version?
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by jarek on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @01:33PM
(#3735440)
No, sorry, I'm not much of an Javascript programmer, neither am I that interested. I realize my post kind of looks like standard wankery-won't-work-himself; I was replying specifically to lukeschlather only regarding whether a jquery dependency is advisable.
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by dko on Tuesday March 20, 2012 @05:30PM
(#3731729)
I totally hear you. The jQuery plugin actually wraps Kicksend.mailcheck, so it's easily decoupled (do fork it!). Since its main use would be on the client side, we released as a plugin for the ease of adoption.