Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by flashmob on Tuesday March 20, 2012 @04:25PM
(#3731337)
email != identity
There are better alternatives to login these days such as OAuth and OpenId, or FB for that matter.
Nerveless, this script could be useful - well done!
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by Splines on Tuesday March 20, 2012 @04:29PM
(#3731350)
Maybe for you, but I prefer using my email address.
It's certainly plausible that Google or FB login is a more pleasant experience for customers, just be aware that a non-zero number of people will bounce from your site if that's all you offer.
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by flashmob on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @06:06AM
(#3733727)
No, I'm not talking about preference here. This is a general observation with email. It's so easy to go and get a throw-away account, which means that email is not best suited for identity as the other solutions. Sure, facebook and OAuth login suck because it gives the website you login to too much access to your data. However, not many hackers know about OpenId and that it's really cool for login. With OpenId, access to your data is more restricted, and the website doesn't have permission to access your account like in OAuth. Google's OpenID gets it right, it is possible to log in to sites without disclosing your email address, and that's how it should be.
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by icebraining on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @06:34AM
(#3733772)
It's so easy to go and get a throw-away account, which means that email is not best suited for identity as the other solutions.
How is that different from OpenID? Creating an account on e.g. MyOpenID is easy enough - you just need to write an username and a password; even the email field is optional.
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by kami8845 on Tuesday March 20, 2012 @05:05PM
(#3731572)
who uses OpenID? I honestly don't know anyone that does, not even hackers
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by flashmob on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @05:57AM
(#3733714)
Do you have a Google Account?
Your Google Account is an OpenId account. So is Yahoo. Many hackers use it without knowing...
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by stefanoric on Wednesday March 21, 2012 @04:57AM
(#3733613)
Stack Exchange sites (e.g. Stackoverflow)?
Re:Mailcheck.js - How we decreased sign up confirmation emai...
by heretohelp on Tuesday March 20, 2012 @04:32PM
(#3731380)
Use something like OAuth, OpenID, or FB where email would suffice, and you lose me as a customer.