I would think the steelman for WFH is the significant number of employees who clearly prefer it.
In all those cases, I'd expect employees to prefer it, but I can see the company having quite different views across the various scenarios.
For myself, I thought I'd absolutely hate working from home full-time. It turns out I love it. I don't think it's obviously good for the company, but I'm not sure how bad vs neutral vs epsilon-positive it is.
>Of the billions in tax incentives granted to US companies every year by cities and states, many agreements require workers to come into the office some of the time, or at least live in the region. For companies receiving these incentives, relaxing in-office attendance could be costly.
>The contracts were crafted in a pre-pandemic era, at a time when commutes to the office were a given. Now governments are deciding whether to crack down or rewrite the rules entirely. In some states and cities, policy changes have already been proposed to account for the new reality of hybrid work.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2023-02-21/another-t...
I'd wager that most people are just as productive or more productive when WFH, but there will always be unethical people who will abuse the privilege when given the chance. There are tons of anecdotes of people just being straight up lazy, defeating naive monitoring solutions with mouse jigglers etc, or committing fraud by working multiple full time jobs concurrently.
When I see someone write “but I love working half time and they have no idea but it all works out” then I’ll pay attention.
Or if even accept at least “I know a lot of people are abusing it”.
Instead it’s all “I’m such an honest worker”.
You know how I know that WFH side isn’t saying using the whole truth? They never look bad.
No one ever says “I’m definitely only working half time, but they’re getting enough work from me so it’s fine” or “I’m being paid more and work less, they’re so clueless they have no idea”, or ”I know a lot of people are scamming but I’m not”.
So while everyone is making the argument that corporate sucks and is out of touch, they’re simultaneously saying they’re angels who would never take advantage.
It’s BS, and everyone on both side knows it.
I think this is a fair criticism but has an understandable explanation. What counts as abuse is not clear cut.
1. With respect to people working half time, you’re going to get push back that people do that in the office as well (inflate estimates and slack or whatever), they just then occupy themselves chatting with coworkers or doing water cooler stuff. From an IC point of view, they’re still slacking. From a corporate point of view maybe these conversations have some added value. Is the absence of them a loss or the lack of willingness to do them from home an abuse?
2. Much more controversially: overemployment. Take the same employee as above but now that they’re working from home instead of chatting they pick up contract hours or work another job. Is this an abuse? Is the company paying for time or output? Is this on the individual or management for underutilizing them?
I could see different kinds of people (being motivated to) making different arguments on each side, and the issues aren’t settled.
Some companies and people are fine with that. Over-employment is worth consideration.
But I think something that is overlooked here is that if you aren’t doing good work, or going all in on everything you do - do something else.
I see no one arguing that. Just “I deserve to work from home because I want to” without any possible consideration to either objectivity of their time /output, reality that a LOT of people scam, or empathy with what these same people would do/think if it was them calling the shots.
WFH people never look bad. Look at this entire thread to find one person that bucks that trend.
If one side is always right, and the other side is always wrong - that just sounds like game to me.
They already have a mechanism for dealing with workers who don't produce up to standards: performance improvement plans (PIP).
The fact they aren't using the existing mechanism and instead are leaning on decree raises some suspicion about their motives.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Seattle/comments/118ihq1/seattle_ma...
https://seattletransitblog.com/2023/02/25/cities-cant-rely-o...
https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/san-francisco-mayo...
https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-08-27/nordstro...
Additionally managers have typically been empowered to evaluate the effectiveness of their teams and their performance, but now an external metric is being forced on them without much visibility into the metrics themselves (e.g. badge in counts for their reports, how WFH while sick but not taking a sick day affects the metric, or various other circumstances). In my experience and prior to the pandemic, whether you were in the office or not was up to whatever discussions you’ve had with your manager, and it some cases there were employees that were allowed to work from home (or other states) based on the needs for that team.
So to me this isn’t returning back to how things used to be, it’s setting a new mandate that drastically impacts an agreement and expectations between the organization that hired the employee and the employee themselves without any data supporting the decision or consideration for what a team actually needs.
On the other hand we had plenty of convincing data that when employees can choose their work style they perform much better individually and as a team.
My theory is that in five years when emotions have cooled and “culture” hand waving is a bit tired, and tax breaks have expired, cold hard money will win the argument and we will be in a “Bring Your Own Office” world.
2. Even if #1 isn't true in an edge case, don't care.
Same with two day weekends. They have to pay extra to get people to work weekends or more than five days a week.
Whether it is more effective or not isn't the point. It's better for workers. The smart companies are doing it voluntarily.
Source:
- https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-andy-jassy-no-data-re...
- https://www.seattletimes.com/business/amazon/amazon-relies-o...
I have to object to your tone. In addition to the arguments you typically hear about uprooting people's lives, this is an extremely deadly policy.
What do you have to say for the people that are going to die because of this? There will be more cancer and disease. The planet will be further damaged. We will be killed, maimed, torn to shreds, and/or burned to death en masse.
This is not a small issue. This is slaughter for the aggrandizement of a few privileged individuals egos.
Twitter, Amazon, Zoom, others are all ending or limiting their WFH programs.
Doesn’t that tell anyone that there MIGHT be facts or at least good research on this that it isn’t producing good work for the money?
I get that “corporations are bad maaaan” and all the good people are dreamy socialists… but what if you are wrong and it isn’t more effective?