News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't use bcrypt by specialist on Tuesday March 20, 2012 @12:31PM (#3730118)
Crypto-based voting systems are not designed to work for real-world elections. They work fine for contrived academic studies.

They all rely on one's vote being lost within a herd of votes. So if your ballot is one of a million, and the ballots are simple with a few races/issues, it's easy to have a secure one-way hash with collisions. (The collisions make it impossible to work backwards to infer how each person voted.)

Alas, real-world elections in the USA are administered at the precinct level. In my state, that's between 0 and 1000 registered voters.

Further, a general election (November) ballot will have dozens of issues and races.

So it's more than likely that any single ballot will be utterly unique. So with the voting systems I studied, it's trivial to infer how everyone voted.

I could imagine crypto-based voting systems working for certain applications. Like corporate shareholder meetings. Or maybe Australian and British style parliamentary elections. (Don't hold me to the last guess, I only have cursory knowledge of their election systems.)

Edit: I discussed these practical issues with one of the grad student authors of a crypto-based voting system. Being completely ignorant of real elections, he had NO IDEA what I was talking about. He denigrated my input; saying our elections should be easily tailored to accommodate crypto. (Good luck with that.)

Maybe it's just me, but I'm of the opinion that people setting out to solve a problem should probably make some token effort to first understand the problem. YMMV.

There are no comments on this comment yet.