Re:Most cancer screenings don’t extend life, study finds
by ilya_m on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:37PM
(#37297708)
I understand the comment's thesis, but I'd like to see more accurate numbers used where real health outcomes are concerned.
The lifetime risk of being diagnosed with colorectal cancer is ~4%. (With the odds trending higher for the younger generation.) The risk of _death_ from this cancer is ~1%.
Re:Most cancer screenings don’t extend life, study finds
by hedora on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:36PM
(#37297678)
Yes, and if you perform dozens of tests per year on the general population, and take action based on the results, then the probabilities add up pretty rapidly.
Re:Most cancer screenings don’t extend life, study finds
by vc8f6vVV on Thursday August 31, 2023 @12:10PM
(#37339483)
> 99.9% of people won't ever get colon cancer, and therefore won't ever benefit from a colonoscopy.
But they may have complications from a colonoscopy, that's the idea. No test is completely harmless, even a blood work. You save some lives but may loose others, that's the point of the paper. And of course you waste resources that can be used to find a cure.
This statement makes it clear what's going on. In ML terms: class imbalance. 99.9% of people won't ever get colon cancer, and therefore won't ever benefit from a colonoscopy. It won't make any statistical difference in overall population survival. But for the 0.1%? It will save their lives.