Re:Scrum is a cancer
by kelnos on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:45AM
(#37294858)
> But if you’re trying to make a process than can take junior devs (not junior in tenure, but junior in the qualities above) and produce an output that scales almost-kinda linearly with dev count, it sort of works.
I don't think that's even the case. I've been brought onto teams of junior (in the sense that you talk about) developers to help fix broken, late projects. Those projects had always been managed under some sort of agile process, and they still ended up in trouble. I wouldn't even say the process "sort of" worked before then. I dunno, maybe it would have been even more of a disaster without the process, but I still don't think that lends much praise to the process.
I'm lucky that I can pick and choose what sort of projects I work on these days, and I will never work at or for a company where I'd be subject to any kind of agile garbage. Another toplevel commenter farther down mentioned a study that showed that projects managed under the "get to work and let me know when it's done" model outperformed all the others. I've always intuitively believed that model can work (though perhaps not in all situations with all types of developers), and it's nice to see some data to back that up.
I don't think that's even the case. I've been brought onto teams of junior (in the sense that you talk about) developers to help fix broken, late projects. Those projects had always been managed under some sort of agile process, and they still ended up in trouble. I wouldn't even say the process "sort of" worked before then. I dunno, maybe it would have been even more of a disaster without the process, but I still don't think that lends much praise to the process.
I'm lucky that I can pick and choose what sort of projects I work on these days, and I will never work at or for a company where I'd be subject to any kind of agile garbage. Another toplevel commenter farther down mentioned a study that showed that projects managed under the "get to work and let me know when it's done" model outperformed all the others. I've always intuitively believed that model can work (though perhaps not in all situations with all types of developers), and it's nice to see some data to back that up.