News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seven Sins of Writing by fasterik on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:30PM (#37287253)
It's a lot more obvious in academic writing. Using a lot of words to make a simple point is often a sign that the writer is trying to signal intelligence rather than convey information.

In literature the goals are different, but I still think the rule applies in most cases. Nabokov is the exception that proves the rule. Great writers have earned the right to be wordy. When an average writer tries write like Nabokov, we call it purple prose.

Re:Seven Sins of Writing by jprete on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:40PM (#37287773)
I mostly agree with you. But I think great writers have, instead, earned the skill of when and how to be wordy for desired effect.
Re:Seven Sins of Writing by watwut on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:37AM (#37290995)
> Nabokov is the exception that proves the rule. Great writers have earned the right to be wordy. When an average writer tries write like Nabokov, we call it purple prose.

When an average writer tries write like Hemmingway, the prose is boring and unreadable. It reads like highschool summary report of the story rather then story.

Also, in non-fiction, writers who use the shortest possible way to express things are super hard to read. Meantime, writers who use more space are often much easier to understand.

Re:Seven Sins of Writing by bitwize on Monday August 28, 2023 @10:59AM (#37295126)
We see this today in movies. Whatever his faults, Joss Whedon is a damn good writer. But today we have a surfeit of inferior writers who make their characters sound "quippy" in imitation of Whedon and these characters become fatiguing to watch.