Re:An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-f...
by version_five on Thursday August 24, 2023 @07:04PM
(#37255687)
It doesn't really work for anything. It would be trivial to defeat this.
Re:An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-f...
by K0balt on Thursday August 24, 2023 @07:23PM
(#37255839)
While I share your reservations, I think we should either give it a whirl or wait for someone else to try adversarial processing before we dismiss it out of hand.
My guess is though that if you had a training set of processed vs unprocessed pairs that you could train an “unmister” if you wanted to.
Re:An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-f...
by TheRealPomax on Thursday August 24, 2023 @07:39PM
(#37255980)
Not much point in giving it a whirl when the resulting images are clearly not something you'd put in your site to show off your work. The problem with this (and glaze, etc) is that it does what it claims by ruining the image it's used on.
Re:An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-f...
by spookie on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:04PM
(#37256141)
Unfortunately it's the natural progression of the web, given the unethical ways people are training their models. This is going to happen in more ways than just images.
Re:An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-f...
by K0balt on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:56PM
(#37256541)
The image degradation seems like certainly a potential dealbreaker from an art perspective. Perhaps in some modalities it would be less noticeable?
Re:An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-f...
by bhickey on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:33PM
(#37256357)
We should dismiss it out of hand. Any image that a human can look at can be fed to a neural net. It's just an instance of the analog hole.
Re:An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-f...
by roughly on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:44PM
(#37256446)
> My guess is though that if you had a training set of processed vs unprocessed pairs that you could train an “unmister” if you wanted to.
I look forward to the masterclass in ethical justification acrobatics that would accompany such an effort
Re:An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-f...
by K0balt on Thursday August 24, 2023 @08:57PM
(#37256547)
Clearly you haven’t met my in-laws.
Re:An image preprocessing tool to protect artworks from AI-f...
by theaiquestion on Friday August 25, 2023 @12:40AM
(#37258148)
Funny enough the first one I've found that works consistently with this one(however unusably destructive) is the "whirl" filter in GIMP.
Previous adversarial methods I've beat with simple noise/blur. This one is fairly resistant to basic filters.
can it work for closed models, like midjourney?