News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study of 160k men finds no all-cause mortality benefit fr... by bermanoid on Monday March 19, 2012 @12:43AM (#3722353)
False positive rates should be understood by the doctors that recommend treatments, though. A doctor should be able to accurately tell a patient what the chance is that they suffer from a disease based on a positive result from a test.

Unfortunately, doctors tend to be terribly bad at this - they are generally quite inept at incorporating prior probabilities into the estimates, and assume that (for instance) if a test has only a 1% false positive rate, then that means a positive result means it's 99% certain that you have whatever it's testing for.

If it's not immediately obvious why that's an idiotically dangerous assessment, then you need to think a bit about a rare disease that only shows up in 1 out of a million people, and then consider the 10,000 people that will test positive for it at a false positive rate of 1%. Don't worry, most doctors don't get this right at first, either, and they will happily suggest to all 10,000 of those people that they seek aggressive, even life-threatening treatment...the difference, of course, is that they're goddamn doctors, entrusted with keeping people alive, and they really ought to know better, whereas you're just some person on the Internet.

Re:Study of 160k men finds no all-cause mortality benefit fr... by carbocation on Monday March 19, 2012 @05:04AM (#3723033)
A classic systems problem. If something is this important, you don't leave it up to the decision of thousands of inhomogenous physicians. You create a system that ensures they don't even get to choose to get it wrong.