The problem is that almost by definition, they have a monopoly on "the market", since each paper is unique and non-fungible, and therefore arguably a separate market. A university can't decide not to subscribe to Cell, for example, and instead get the same research from other journals. This is a good thing (since it means research effort isn't being duplicated), but it means you can't just "break up" a publisher to bring pricing in line with a competitive market.
I wish the NIH or NSF would require that all published studies from their grants be placed in the public domain.
I talked about force. I think you disagree with me but you don't say so directly.
Who are you saying is or isn't using force? What did I say that you disagree with?
Did you get the wrong idea that I was defending the journal companies? So your angry emotions got the better of you? I didn't defend them. I said the researchers are even better than the article suggests. As far as I can tell that puts us on the same side, yet you're pissed off and ranting at me.
EDIT: downvoting this too, still with zero explanation? this didn't used to happen. maybe HN really is getting worse.
Arguing that a large-scale, organized boycott does not constitute "coercion or compulsion" or that anything that does not involve physical violence should not be called a "fight" is just inane.
How is it "nitpicking" to talk about whether something uses violence or not?
It's nitpicking to argue about the definition of words, especially when the usage you're criticizing is a widely accepted figurative use.
These journal companies are charging Universities millions of dollars annually. And when I say millions annually, they charge each and every separate University library millions of dollars. Yet, all these companies do is host a few hundred thousand PDF documents. I could do that for a about a hundred dollars a year on Dreamhost.
The journal companies essentially have a monopoly on the market. They must and should be broken up for the good of scientific research. The studies were funded by the public, and should be accessible to the public.