But any internet blogger can make it sound so easy, as if the government can just say, "Ok banks, time to break up," especially in the current political climate. My uninformed guess is that the government has other worries, and wants to see how the Volcker rule pans out.
...and please don't imagine to the temptation that the world is not the way you want it because of the lack of a leader, or something. This stuff is heavily politicized and very complicated, and part of that complication is because of the generations of regulators who said 'something must be done'.
All I see is Obama's top team being very cozy with the big banks, and the Republicans would let BofA institute gas chambers as long as it was "free market". Where's 'the government wanting to break them up' in that?
The impression I've gotten is that the financial world is convinced that Obama is out to get them, so of course it's "common knowledge" that he has a plan to break up the banks. But what's he actually done? The settlement with the big banks a couple months ago was a slap on the wrist at best, and removed a huge liability.
My brain parses that as: people whose roles will require experience and insight in dealing with huge sums of money and complex economic effects at the national level TURN OUT to also be the kind of people you'd want to hire for other roles that benefit from applying experience and insight in dealing with huge sums of money and complex economic effects at the national level.
Now, if they're corrupt, that would be a bad thing. But having prior relevant experience? A good thing.
What I said is that the financial industry, as of recently, has had an antagonistic relationship with the government, and that this is common knowledge in the industry. That's how they see it, anyway. There's a lot of tiptoeing the government has to do, because they're still counting on commercial banks to clear the housing market, to have their back on distressed bank mergers, etc.
Anyway, I'd rather see top bankers in those positions than top politicians. Obama's a moderate and a technocrat; so your thesis isn't distinguishable from the null hypothesis.
Something must be done! This is something we can all agree on. This must be done!
I also think an insightful leader can propose actions that disrupt the status quo and leave the world a better place.
I posit that the internet would not have been able to take-off the way it did if the DOJ had not successfully broken up AT&T. Remember there used to be exactly one company who owned the phone lines running into your house and across the country. Since they owned the wires they decided what equipment you could hook onto their wires - which happened to be only equipment they sold and installed.
Because they're too big not to lobby.
ie. Make Bank of America a wet coast only bank again.
But if I had to bet, my money would be on some travesty against the US taxpayer like Bear Stearns good assets sold for close to nothing and taxpayers taking the junk mortgage assets.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bear_Stearns#Fed_bailout_and_sa...
But current BofA management will keep complicating it as long as possible, maximizing their income. Also the legal pandora's box of imminent lawsuits makes thing very bleak.
This system might be an example of local inefficiencies that lead to a healthier whole. Big companies are supposed to benefit from "economies of scale", but are there any big companies that are not the wasteful, ineffective bureaucracies featured in Dilbert?
What about governments?
If there are companies that are "too big to fail" and therefore should be broken up, surely the US govt should also be broken up. (CA's govt may qualify as well.)
I am regular reader of Charles Hugh Smith's "Of Two Minds" blog:
http://charleshughsmith.blogspot.com/
He has a recent post where he compares the Dodd-Frank supposed reform bill (over 2300 pages!) to the Glass Steagall act (37 pages)
http://charleshughsmith.blogspot.com/2012/03/we-have-no-othe...
He goes on to provide a common sense, 5 paragraph law that would provide some actual reform to our banking system.