Re:70 years ago, an Anglo-US coup condemned Iran to decades ...
by jltsiren on Monday August 21, 2023 @12:37PM
(#37211970)
Presidents have had similar powers in many presidential republics. For example, Finland was like that until ~30 years ago. Ultimately it doesn't matter much if the head of state is a king or a president. It doesn't even matter that much what they could do in exceptional situations, or whether they inherited their position or were elected to it.
What matters is the tradition of running a normal democracy. If the elections are fair, if the ones who lose their power step down gracefully, if there is a peaceful transition of power, and so on. If you have a tradition of that, adapting a different form of democratic government is not that hard.
Re:70 years ago, an Anglo-US coup condemned Iran to decades ...
by leereeves on Monday August 21, 2023 @04:48PM
(#37215152)
> It doesn't even matter that much ... whether they inherited their position or were elected to it.
> What matters is the tradition of running a normal democracy
A country ruled by a hereditary leader with virtually unlimited power could hardly be called a normal democracy.
It does matter how much power the elected officials have.
Yes, some of the small states in the empire were democratic, but that only added to the instability of the whole after 1918 as the Weimar Republic tried to unite people with very different histories.