Re:Female genital mutilation, leading cause of death in Afri...
by invalidname on Sunday August 20, 2023 @12:45AM
(#37196191)
I understood there isn't consensus around that. If that were the case HIV would be far more widespread in Europe than the states.
This is a much better resource: https://arstechnica.com/science/2015/02/the-troubled-history...
Re:Female genital mutilation, leading cause of death in Afri...
by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Sunday August 20, 2023 @11:28AM
(#37200052)
So, the person being circumcised can tradeoff less sex pleasure for less chance of HIV.
How about asking them before circumcising?
Re:Female genital mutilation, leading cause of death in Afri...
by water-data-dude on Monday August 21, 2023 @02:39PM
(#37213620)
I agree.
In the case of using male circumcision as a prophylaxis against HIV in Africa, the programs I read about were aimed at adult men.
Re:Female genital mutilation, leading cause of death in Afri...
by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Monday August 21, 2023 @05:11PM
(#37215422)
Makes sense.
Still painful to read, we didn't cut fingers because hands could transmit and kill covid, but I understand this analogy is not in the same ballpark.
Basically, it looks like there’s a consensus that for vaginal sex (and probably anal sex) it can reduce the risk of contracting HIV for the penetrative partner. It’s much less effective than condom use or something like PrEP, but it makes a lot of sense in some high risk populations. Right now it’s being actively encouraged in Africa. HIV has been exploding over there and, while condom use, tests, and PrEP are more effective, it’s hard to get a steady supply to the people who would benefit - and then hard to get them to use condoms/take PrEP/get tested consistently. It’s less effective, but it’s a one and done thing that will reduce the risk somewhat, so hopefully it’ll help put the brakes on.
I don’t think male circumcision makes a lot of sense in developed countries in most cases, since we have easy access to a steady supply of condoms, PrEP, and testing - as well as medicine to clear up UTIs and such. The medical community is somewhat divided though, so IDK.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circumcision#Prophylactic_usag...