News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Short session expiration does not help security by horsawlarway on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:18PM (#37178921)
> One thing I see all the time that demonstrates this incompetence is talking about something being more or less "secure" without reference to a threat model. You simply can't make reasonable tradeoffs without thinking this through, and yet nobody wants to do the exercise.

Hey - I completely 100% agree. Believe it or not, I did quite a stint in software security before becoming this jaded (5+ years fulltime work at a security focused product sold primarily to large fortune 100 companies [banks - it was all banks]).

I think my problem is that for any difficult challenge... there is an answer that is simple, obvious, and incorrect.

My opinion is that the incorrect answers I see most are the two extremes: I don't care about security (BAD!). I only care about security (WORSE!!!!).

The first will eventually lead to compromised accounts/data and that can kill a company. The second will lead to products no one wants to use, which WILL kill a company.

Neither is a good spot to be. You want to find an appropriate compromise in the middle: Secure enough.

----

Side note - no one truly does the threat assessments based on threat model because no one in industry likes the answers.

For small and inconsequential threats - you are already secure enough.

For nation states - there is likely no solution that is workable if the thing is on the internet.

It's like trying to buy a secure door for your house: For most folks walking down the street, the current door is fine. When the Gov shows up with tanks - there is no door you can buy to solve the problem.

There are no comments on this comment yet.