News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My resignation letter as R7RS-large chair by jacquesm on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:41AM (#37173798)
> My impression (from far on the outside) is that Racket has taken up a lot of the oxygen

For real world applications rather than education Racket and Clojure as well, in fact Clojure has taken up a lot of the oxygen across a variety of niche FP language eco systems. The Clojure toolchain and library support (much of it through the JVM and Java ecosystem) is excellent and far ahead of Racket for most of the same applications. But Racket starts faster and has a much smaller memory footprint. Depending on your workload and compatibility demands either the one or the other will be a clear favorite with Clojure coming out ahead.

But all of these and scheme (which I think is mostly propped up by virtue of being used a lot in education, I've yet to come across scheme in the wild) are very much niche languages. Clojure really does have an advantage of standing on the shoulders of Java and the JVM, without that I don't think it would have gotten as large as it did.

Re:My resignation letter as R7RS-large chair by wokwokwok on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:31AM (#37174746)
…but, we were talking about scheme, not clojure right?

> Clojure really does have an advantage of…

Look, I’m a fan of clojure, I spent two happy years using it. …but it seems obnoxious to bring it up here like this.

Is there really any reason to think that clojure has taken the wind out of the sails of the group of people who were using scheme?

It seems like a massive, totally unsubstantiated take, that really doesn’t add anything here.

Re:My resignation letter as R7RS-large chair by jacquesm on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:43AM (#37174871)
Well, that may be your impression. But I know of two cases where scheme was being considered for commercial work and in both of those the decision was made to go for Clojure instead. It was relative to Racket as a replacement for more real world applications of Scheme that I mentioned this.
Re:My resignation letter as R7RS-large chair by munificent on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:31PM (#37178095)
The aggression in your response is entirely disproportionate to the comment you're replying to. I don't know who peed in your Cheerios, but it wasn't jacquesm.

We're talking about a minimal dynamically-typed Lisp language and speculating about its challenges around adoption and consensus. Given that Lisps are already a niche language, it's completely germane to bring up another minimal dynamically-typed Lisp that has almost certainly captured some of the overall small potential userbase.