Re:Metallica Hard-Wires a Different Set List Every Night
by veave on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:03AM
(#37173511)
There's something I don't understand. He's been a drummer for 40 years now. How can he still be "not good"?
Re:Metallica Hard-Wires a Different Set List Every Night
by enneff on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:24AM
(#37174199)
Probably because he doesn’t dedicate himself to the craft. Musicians tend to get better with age, not worse.
Re:Metallica Hard-Wires a Different Set List Every Night
by midoridensha on Monday August 21, 2023 @12:42AM
(#37205571)
To a point. Drumming requires a lot more stamina than other instruments, so after a certain point, drummers have a hard time playing as well as they did when younger. We're seeing this now with Iron Maiden's Nicko McBrain, who's over 70. It's not like this for guitars/bass, but again with Iron Maiden, people are saying that they aren't running around the stage they way they did in the past.
Age isn't Lars's problem though.
Re:Metallica Hard-Wires a Different Set List Every Night
by xinayder on Saturday August 19, 2023 @05:18AM
(#37186975)
the only time they didn't criticize him was back in the 90s when the whole band was high on drugs all the time, I guess.
Re:Metallica Hard-Wires a Different Set List Every Night
by raverbashing on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:09AM
(#37173559)
He's probably better than anyone in The Clash for example
Technical prowess only goes so far, Metallica got where it got with him, and in the end it's a moot point
Yeah maybe he's not the best drummer, but it was good enough to get them where they got
I think for quite some time James and Jason were the best musicians in the band. Now Trujillo is far and away the most serious and capable musician among them.
That’s not to take away from the whole package. Cleary together they do (or did) something people love. But there is some objective notion of musical skill and capability that you can judge them by, and Lars is just not that great.