I don't think that candidates who spend less time or turn in incomplete take homes are necessarily at a disadvantage. Sooo much can be discerned from a take home even if it's not finished. I can evaluate a candidate's familiarity with modern syntax, how they organize functions, how readable their code is, whether or not they used ChatGPT/CoPilot or copy/pasted from an online tutorial (surprisingly easy to discern when you're evaluating many submissions), and so on.
All of that tells me a lot about how well someone functions as an engineer, as well as what level they're operating at, and it doesn't require the completion of the take home problem.
What you're really asking for is a candidate to spend extra time inventing a convincing git history.
I really think the only way this actually works is if the problem is on a page which you can only view after you start a timer or something.
Or do it on site and watch them.
This is all high pressure but if you really want to time box, there can't be a way around it.