Re:Captain Zilog Crushed: The Story of the Z8000
by krylon on Thursday August 17, 2023 @10:39AM
(#37162387)
I was under the impression RISC architectures usually(?) don't use microcode. Or am I mistaken?
Re:Captain Zilog Crushed: The Story of the Z8000
by monocasa on Thursday August 17, 2023 @10:58AM
(#37162718)
Correct, true RISCs tend to not use microcode. ARM historically has, but it's also always been a bit of a RISC/CISC hybrid.
Re:Captain Zilog Crushed: The Story of the Z8000
by kens on Thursday August 17, 2023 @10:59AM
(#37162727)
The NEC V33 (1988) was a hardwired (not microcoded) version of the 286. The decision not to use microcode might be related to the long lawsuit between Intel and NEC over microcode.
Also, as krylon points out, RISC chips generally don't use microcode.
Re:Captain Zilog Crushed: The Story of the Z8000
by MichaelZuo on Thursday August 17, 2023 @11:17AM
(#37162999)
Thanks Ken, that's pretty fascinating info. It makes me wonder if, with modern design software, a modern 64 bit CPU could be made without any microcode either.
Re:Captain Zilog Crushed: The Story of the Z8000
by monocasa on Thursday August 17, 2023 @01:51PM
(#37165528)
Depending on what you mean by modern, there are RISC-V cores that don't use microcode, including 64-bit OoOE cores like SonicBOOM and the T-Head C920.
Re:Captain Zilog Crushed: The Story of the Z8000
by dfawcus on Thursday August 17, 2023 @01:49PM
(#37165497)
According to the datasheet, which I've just looked at, it was not a '286 equivalent. Rather it added a paging mechanism whereby a 20 bit 'linear' address was mapped to a 24 bit 'physical' address. Using 1024 16k pages, so a bit like an internal LIM 4.0 scheme, but limited to 16M total rather than 24M.
It has a pair of new instructions, to enter and exit the extended mapping mode, and the mappings are only changeable when not in the extended mapping mode. So a form of memory protection.
See pages 20 and 21 of the following:
https://datasheet.datasheetarchive.com/originals/scans/Scans...
“… there are so many instructions in Z8000 it is impossible to store all of test vector for debugging in the memory of test bench anymore. Also, MOS process was getting denser and denser and also the size of the defects in masks was getting smaller. That is it was not so easy to find the fully functional die.”
This seems like a remarkable engineering decision to go entirely without microcode. Are there any comparable examples post 1979?