News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Captain Zilog Crushed: The Story of the Z8000 by ajross on Thursday August 17, 2023 @09:16AM (#37161084)
> This was even though Intel’s 8086 was, by many measures, a design that was markedly inferior to the Z8000.

I don't see this as true at all. The 8086 segment registers are fine-grained, so you can use the single 16 bit value in a single register as a "pointer" to memory as long as you're OK with your blocks being allocated in 16 byte chunks and don't try to do array indexing on the raw value. This doesn't match the C memory model well, but it's very usable and for years DOS software exploited this trick to get clean addressing across the full 1M memory space of the PC with near-zero overhead[1].

The Z8000 had two-register addresses[2] and you needed to carry those two full words around everywhere. It's equivalent to writing DOS software with the "Huge" memory model pervasively (something pretty much no performance-sensitive software did, historically), because that's all the CPU could support. It's a big, big loss.

And all you get back for your trouble is a bigger register set, which looks great in a ISA document but doesn't really make up for the terrible memory access design. Zilog spent their transistors on the wrong things.

[1] Not zero, because there are only two usable segment registers to hold these pointers, but then the architecture had only 4 true GPRs anyway.

[2] IIRC (and seemingly confirmed by a quick wikipedia check) not even linear ones! The "segment offset" wasn't packed next to the low address bits. So you can't even do natural math on arrays bigger 64kb.

There are no comments on this comment yet.