News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Times considers legal action against OpenAI as c... by dragonwriter on Thursday August 17, 2023 @04:44AM (#37158885)
> You don’t need a fair use exemption for transient copies in service of licensed or fair uses.

The transient copy isn’t for a licensed use, and whether it is a Fair Use is specifically the subject of debate. So this really is basically an admission that but for the potential applicability of Fair Use, the use of the copyrighted mmaterial in training is a violation of copyright.

Also, even if the training is fair use, that doesn’t mean that the copies of the source material produced by OpenAI and distributed to their customers using the model are fair use. Just becaue making the tool is a transformative fair use doesn’t mean using the tool to generate copies of the material which was used to train it, which are significantly less trandormative than the model itself, are Fair Use. (And the fact that one of the functions that the model is used for is this commercial, for profit by the maker of the model, copying of the source material is – as much as I believe AI model training on its own is quite likely to generally be fair use – an argument against the model training being fair use in this csase.)

> Computers and networks have been around a long time.

True, and commercially producing and delivery copies of copyrighted works in a manner which substitutes for the original work in the marketplace, no matter what intermediate steps go into doing that, and no matter that computers or networks are used in those intermediate steps, is pretty much the clearest case of violation of copyright you can get.

> These issues have been given a good workout.

Some of them have, some of them have not. Whether and in what conditions training an AI on source material that may be subject in aggregate to a compilation copyright by someone else, and which consists further of individual works that have their own copyrights, might be “fair use” is not one of the issues that have been given a good workout. Neither – because producing predictive models in that way has not previously been common – has whether, unlike other intermediate tool use, using such a model in the course of doing what would otherwise be an infringement by producing a copy of specific copyright-protected works, commercially, for a customer at their request, is no longer a violation because the use of the model somehow isolates it from liability,

There are no comments on this comment yet.