News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by kragen on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @05:45PM (#37139670)
it's not war

hashicorp has decided they don't want to contribute to open source any more

they're totally within their rights to do so, and it doesn't harm anybody; it's not the equivalent of going around blowing up buildings, raping women, and napalming children. at most we can wish they had continued doing the beneficial things they were previously doing

maybe they'll change their minds, as you say, but that's no reason for the community to sit around twiddling its thumbs hoping for such a change. what's important now is that the people who are still willing to cooperate can do so successfully, and that's what opentf is about

that's even more obviously not the equivalent of going around blowing up buildings, raping women, and napalming children. it's very much the opposite, in fact

it's unclear to me which of the parties you intend to accuse of doing the moral equivalent of burning innocent people alive en masse, but either way, maybe you should think about walking back that rhetoric a bit

Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by fishnchips on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @06:10PM (#37139929)
I apologize if I appeared to downplay the horror of actual war. I'm lucky to never have experienced it first-hand.

I mainly wanted to focus on the "civil" than "war" aspect of the possible schism.

Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by anyoneamous on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @06:31PM (#37140129)
FWIW there are still people (dozens of us!) who don't feel the need to be artificially offended by a bit of hyperbole on an internet forum.
Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by bifrost on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:01PM (#37140996)
I concurr.
Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by kragen on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @12:28AM (#37142889)
my objection is not that mass graves, piles of mangled bodies, your close friends unexpectedly disappearing into pink mist, and terrible stenches are too sacred to be used as a metaphor for something else

my objection is that warfare involves people intentionally harming each other, and that doesn't seem to be what's going on here. it's not that war is a more extreme version of the situation; it's that it's directionally different

rather, hashicorp is struggling to not go bankrupt, so they've decided to switch to making a proprietary product instead of an open-source products; and terraform users, naturally enough, are reluctant to make their infrastructure vulnerable to a proprietary software license. hashicorp is not intentionally harming terraform users, and terraform users are not intentionally harming hashicorp

they're just not continuing their previous cooperation

Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by 0ct4via on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @12:22PM (#37149419)
Not sacred enough for you to invoke the Holocaust in a discussion about data protection legislation and the "right to be forgotten" within mere hours of this statement, however...

Such hypocrisy, attacking others for "rhetoric" that needs to be "dialled back a bit" when you're every bit as guilty of the exact. same. thing.

Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by kragen on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @01:12PM (#37150201)
please note that the comment you are replying to says the opposite of what you are implying it does

the comment you are referring to, for anyone who is interested, concerns the question of whether or not there is a higher standard of morality to which legislation can be held, or whether legislation itself is the ultimate moral authority, or whether there is in fact no objective standard of morality at all. anyone who is interested in that kind of thing can read it at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37147305

Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by kragen on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @06:30PM (#37140123)
it's not a possible schism. hashicorp has clearly and unmistakably abandoned the open source community. conceivably they'll change their minds, but their communication doesn't have any ambiguity in it

i have no idea what you could possibly mean by 'focus on the "civil"'. it's good that people are being civil to one another, isn't it?

Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by tedivm on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @07:11PM (#37140515)
You're missing the point- the OpenTF group wants to mend the schism if possible, by getting Hashicorp to change their licensing back. If they immediately fork then that's not likely to happen, so they're attempting this first.

I don't think it will work, but I think it's good of them to try.

Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by kragen on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:33PM (#37141244)
mending the schism would be great, but we probably can't do that by pretending it doesn't exist, analogizing it to blowing children's extremities off, or analogizing acknowledging its existence to blowing children's extremities off; I'm still not sure which of the latter two was the intent of the comment I was responding to
Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by 0ct4via on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @12:22PM (#37149424)
Don't you think you should check yourself before attacking others?

> "it's unclear to me which of the parties you intend to accuse of doing the moral equivalent of burning innocent people alive en masse, but either way, maybe you should think about walking back that rhetoric a bit"

... but only earlier today were you equating a data protection law with the Holocaust... seems you could do with a bit less projection and rhetoric yourself, Kraggy.

Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by kragen on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @01:18PM (#37150291)
this is careless reasoning; rather than equating a so-called 'data protection law' with the holocaust, i said the justification others were using for that law was incorrect, because if it were correct, it would also justify the holocaust

this is not an extremely advanced form of logic, but i understand that it is not within everyone's grasp

the comment in question is https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37147305

octavia's other, rather astounding comment in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37149528 is probably also useful context

my objection to the war rhetoric in this case is that it casts people as opponents who are not, in fact, opponents, just different parties pursuing largely independent interests. in that context playing 'let's you and him fight' seems unlikely to improve the situation

Re:The OpenTF Manifesto by 0ct4via on Monday August 21, 2023 @04:15AM (#37206712)
Why use so-called? It's literally a law concerning data protection. Unless you feel that the empirical truth somehow shouldn't be used to describe the GDPR and colloquial "right to be forgotten" aspects it entails, you're just trolling for trolling's sake -- either that, or you don't even know that you're using "so-called" improperly.

Once again you jump to mansplaining and condescension, followed by failing to even get a username correct when it's literally on your screen.

Your repeated attempts to tell people what they think, what they do or do not know, and where they live, show that every observation of you being arrogant, condescending, and disingenuous, is patently correct.

Unsure if you need a shovel to get out of that hole you've put yourself in, but you're sure backpedaling quickly, yikes.