Re:The Hip Hop Historians Who Are Racing to Preserve Its Sto...
by jrm4 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:15PM
(#37138805)
Would you really make this argument with any other cultural contribution? Come on.
You think it's insulting to assign the Hula to Hawaiians? This makes NO sense.
Re:The Hip Hop Historians Who Are Racing to Preserve Its Sto...
by qntty on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:22PM
(#37138879)
I don't know the significance of hula, but if it doesn't aspire to be something great, then assigning it to Hawaiians wouldn't be an insult, since it doesn't contradict their own view of it.
People will often times contextualize things to downplay it's importance. For example, if I think it's disrespectful to talk about hip hop in a certain way, you can contextualize my view by saying it's an outgrowth of early 21st century American progressive legitimation narratives. I want my views to be universal, but by placing them in the context of a certain country, time, and ideology, they are downplayed.
If I was a hip hop artist, there would be no bigger insult than assigning ownership of my art to a specific culture. If it's really so great, it should speak to everyone. If this isn't true of Irish step dancing, it's because it's a relatively trivial art form. You can trivialize hip hop too if you want, but it's not necessarily doing hip hop artists any favors.