News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lack of Walkability in the US is destroying mental health by moritzwarhier on Monday August 14, 2023 @03:18PM (#37125537)
Avering air pollution (noise pollution is just as bad, btw) over a huge metropolitan area is not a meaningful metric.

My city also has "good air quality". They even made a successful effort to change EU thresholds for pollutants to achieve that, while at the same time placing AQ measurement devices in unrealistic places.

But that didn't suffice.

Then there's the fact that metropolitan areas include many suburbs where the distinction if they belong to the city is arbitrary at best.

Good air quality in a rich part if the city where an average citizen occupies/owns/rents 10x the space of the average from the poorer areas doesn't improve health. Weirdly, the places with the least amount of car traffic are also the ones with the highest number of parked cars. Of course this ceases to be a metric when one person owns 100x of the area that another person rents. Rich people don't like to look at cars in their backyard, right?

A park that is not accessible without a car also does not improve the health of people workinf on the city who can't afford a car.

Might be NYC has great air quality, but the meat of your argument doesn't stand up to scrutiny IMO.

Also, why focus on select cities and with selective maximums in some metric?

Why not do actual epidemiology?

Re:Lack of Walkability in the US is destroying mental health by ch4s3 on Monday August 14, 2023 @05:28PM (#37127048)
You aren't going to see meaningfully different air pollution levels in micro areas most of the time unless there's something like a highway or large source of smoke. If you look at AQI measurements around NYC they're all within about 10 points, excluding 1 sensor that's right by a huge bus depot, and it's 20 points higher than the minimum, but maybe 10-15 above the average.

Also, noise pollution DEFINITELY isn't just as bad as air pollution. No doubt it CAN cause stress and CAN disrupt sleep, but air pollution is clearly a far bigger problem in general.