I think you wanted to reply to the same person I replied to? Since I'm saying basically the same thing you do I believe
Re:Software Engineering at Google
by robertlagrant on Monday August 14, 2023 @01:36PM
(#37123969)
> "were [sic] not google" is usually good for things where people are using cargo cult
It's no different to cargo culting. That should not be the reason for not doing something, any more than the opposite should be a reason for doing it. Just see if the practice makes sense in your context and decide that way.
Re:Software Engineering at Google
by marcosdumay on Monday August 14, 2023 @05:14PM
(#37126879)
"We are not Google" is the answer to "I saw on that blog here that we should do X", "everybody is doing X, we should too", or "you have to follow this good practice here" where the practice is only "good" because it's hyped.
Those kinds of demand happen exactly because they saw them at Google, and an outright refusal is exactly how they should be dealt with. Once the unreasonable person is cut out, you can look at your context and decide what's the best way to solve the problem.
Also sometimes you just need a simple tool to get something done. As engineers we like to build things so sometimes we make it way more complex than it really needs to be. For someone like google that may just be fine to do. For others a minimum viable product may be in order. Do not worry about optimizing for the 3 million user per day case when you have 10 total users a month. Add logging and keep an eye on it. Then worry if you need to scale. As building good scale takes time and thought. Many times you do not need that at all.
As your company/group grows you will take on more and more of the things 'google does' because you will need to, or you will go nuts chasing everything. You could probably even make stages out of the different times to do/evaluate things. To do it early could actually harm what you are doing. You need to evaluate what you are doing and why. Just copying someone else does not always lead to a good outcome and you could be wasting effort when you could be making product.