Reddit is the most prominent. It's had a huge impact although from what I understand it hasn't done extremely well financially.
That's quite a halo effect that has prevented you from seeing the true "success rate".
Where are you getting 5 acquisitions from?
Reddit, Loopt basically made out.
Infogami merged with Reddit. That's essentially a save face maneuver and doesn't exactly signal success.
Clickfacts - "YC stake acquired by private investors" doesn't sound like that would be a win but a break even. More like "take it off our hands".
Kiko - Sold in an ebay auction for 258,000.
http://gigaom.com/2006/09/05/tucows-bought-kiko/
http://tucowsinc.com/news/2006/09/why-we-bought-kikocom/
I'd give it 2.1 out of 8.
The founders of Loopt, the Reddits, and Justin.tv have done a lot for the YC program (and for startups in general) going forward; arguably these 3 moderate successes financially for YC but having very involved alumni might be worth more than a huge financial success which didn't stay involved with YC.
"Wow, that's phenomenal. In 7 years, out of 8 companies there were 5 acquisitions (and a couple mergers). I'm sure any VC would be ecstatic to have that kind of success rate."
I don't see how that statement has anything to do with the value of the founders.
He said "5 acquisitions" not "2 (or 3) acquisitions and additionally they have very involved alumni.
Kiko - Acquired by Tucows, team founded Justin.tv
Loopt - Raised 15million in Series A and B financing, at it's peak was valued at $500m, sold for $40m to Green Dot
Simmery - Closed. Founder went back to uni.
Infogami - Merged with Reddit.
MemAmp - Never launched, one founder (Chris) joined reddit one (Zak) went back to uni.
FireCrawl - Never launched, team founded TextPayMe and got acquired by amazon.
ClickFacts - YC stake acquired by private investors because YC wasn't a good fit. Company still exists.