News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

The way we diagnose ADHD is severely flawed

Ever since I found out about ADHD I've been very skeptical of it. Especially adult ADHD and most especially adult-onset ADHD.

People with ADHD struggle to focus and procrastinate often.

But everyone experiences this.

The usual retort to this is: "but I have been diagnosed by a medical professional", and therefore I need medication so my condition can be treated.

But does anyone stop to ask what being diagnosed actually means?

There is a book of guidelines published/updated every 10 years or so called DSM, currently at DSM-5-TR.

> The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-5-TR) was published in 2022. It involved more than 200 experts, the majority of whom were involved in the development of DSM-5.

There is a set of qualitative criteria, and if you fit a given number of them you have it.

But then the question becomes: why should we use these criteria?

The history is quite interesting, as the definition has evolved from DSM-1 to DSM-5-TR.

What you end up finding though is that the definition and diagnosis of ADHD is circular.

From [ADHD in the DSM-5-TR: What has changed and what has not](https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9871920) (2023/01/10):

> “if an individual has attention deficit hyperactivity disorder it is because he is inattentive, disorganized and hyperactive-impulsive, and if an individual is inattentive, disorganized and hyperactive-impulsive it is because he has ADHD.

> Without concrete and objective evidence of an identifiable brain disorder there is nothing that explains behaviors associated with ADHD diagnosis. ADHD as a diagnostic entity remains a descriptive classification of behaviors, not an explanation for them. When behaviors are explained by using a descriptive classification, adhering to circular reasoning is inescapable.

So contrary to what people think, nothing actually explains the brain disorder:

> the authors state that “no biological marker is diagnostic for ADHD” and that “meta-analysis of all neuroimaging studies do not show differences between individuals with ADHD and control subjects”, thus “no form of neuroimaging can be used for diagnosis of ADHD”.

And then you have studies like this one: [The prevalence of adult attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder: A global systematic review and meta-analysis](https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7916320/) (2021/02/11) that conclude:

> the prevalence of persistent adult ADHD was 2.58% and that of symptomatic adult ADHD [regardless of a childhood onset] was 6.76%, translating to 139.84 million and 366.33 million affected adults in 2020 globally.

And that makes 4.18% of adult-onset...even more than childhood ADHD (2.58%)!

Whoa, that's a lot of people! 1 in 20 people.

It's also a shit ton of money for meds.

The global ADHD therapeutics market size is estimated to be worth USD 29.56 billion in 2022 and USD 45.68 billion by 2027.

So we really could be pumping people full of meds everyday for their whole life because they think they have a brain disorder...when they might actually just be addicted to their phone.

( 8 comments | on HN )
Re:The way we diagnose ADHD is severely flawed by SophieSoftly on Sunday August 13, 2023 @04:50PM (#37114307)
I wish I had enough karma to vote this redundant drivel down. If you don't experience ADHD as debilitating in everyday life, then congratulations to you, you don't have it.
Re:The way we diagnose ADHD is severely flawed by richardjam73 on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:28PM (#37116812)
If I had a dollar for every layman on the internet who misunderstood the DSM I would be very rich.
Re:The way we diagnose ADHD is severely flawed by coldtea on Sunday August 13, 2023 @05:02PM (#37114438)
>People with ADHD struggle to focus and procrastinate often. But everyone experiences this. The usual retort to this is "but I have been diagnosed by a medical professional"

No, the usual retort is the argument that "everyone experiences this" is irrelevant.

It's the degree to which a person experiences it, and the impact it has to their life is what is relevant.

Same as how everyone forgets things sometimes, but not everybody has dementia.

Or how everyone oversleeps sometimes, but not everyone has narcolepsia.

Not to mention that "struggling to focus and procrastinating often" is just one aspect of ADHD. There are also sensory issues, stimming, over-fixations, memory issues, and several other things.

>Whoa, that's a lot of people! 1 in 20 people

Other mental and body issues have even bigger spread. Doesn't mean they don't exist. Check how many people are depressed (way more than 1 in 20), whether they take drugs for it or not.

>the authors state that “no biological marker is diagnostic for ADHD” and that “meta-analysis of all neuroimaging studies do not show differences between individuals with ADHD and control subjects”, thus “no form of neuroimaging can be used for diagnosis of ADHD”.

Yes. Several diseases are like that.

Not everything boils down to "you lack this protein in your system" or "your heart has a blocked artery" that can be seen trivially. Some diagnosis require observation and nuance, instead of a mechanical test, who would have thought?

Some issues occur because of developmental issues in brain connectivity and which brain "modules" overwork or underwork. Those aren't

That said, some of the results of that can be seen in brain scans of ADHD vs regular brains, even if we don't know the exact cause of ADHD in children.

That's the case with most diseases: we first see the symptoms and learn to identify them, we might be able to also find some way to aleviate them, and only after centuries or decades or research (if we're lucky), we find the causes.

You seem like you gave the thing a few days worth of thought (not necessarily just a few days of actual calendar time, just a few days worth of though), and decided you have the right idea, and others are stupid or in it for profit.

I suggest you go live for a good while with someone who has ADHD and see if what they have is just them "struggling to focus and procrastinating often" they same way every Average Joe "experiences it sometimes", and whether they're just "addicted to their phone".

Re:The way we diagnose ADHD is severely flawed by Swordfish12345 on Sunday August 13, 2023 @07:27PM (#37115664)
> some of the results of that can be seen in brain scans of ADHD vs regular brains, even if we don't know the exact cause of ADHD.

And others don't...https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/imaging-study-shows-dopa...

Every medicated person you ask tells you their brain just works differently from birth and doesn't produce enough dopamine so they need meds...but its not proven at all, and there is evidence its not the case.

> and only after centuries or decades or research (if we're lucky), we might pinpoint the exact mechanisms.

We might also create such a broad definition of a condition (that we just thought up), and then unnecessary put healthy people on meds and fuck up society.

Advocates always talk like there are no consequences to taking stimulants every day...but you read story after story. It just doesn't make sense, if its safe, then everyone can have it, if not, then...we just make up definitions of it and people who fit that pattern can have it?

> see if what they have is just them "struggling to focus and procrastinating often"

That's not the point. The definition of ADHD clearly defines them as struggling a lot more than the usual person.

ADHD is simply a grouping of behaviors. 126 different combinations in fact.

How does this make it a singular condition that we just throw meds at?

The whole industry just feels like an excuse to prescribe meds. Meds which help everyone.

Re:The way we diagnose ADHD is severely flawed by JimtheCoder on Sunday August 13, 2023 @05:06PM (#37114479)
You must be new here.

Telling people who have ADHD they don't actually have ADHD and that they should just focus harder is not the best use of your time...

Re:The way we diagnose ADHD is severely flawed by effed3 on Sunday August 13, 2023 @05:20PM (#37114644)
>People with ADHD struggle to focus and procrastinate often. >But everyone experiences this.

Living in a "modern" society, complex, fast, competitive-driven, with 24hr news and fake-news feeds, etc etc etc.. who can really avoid this "problem"? I suspect so many "mental problems" are in reality others kind of problems, diguised as mental, and many solutions are a cure for symptoms but not a remedy for -real- true causes, clearly with enough of a stress or situation sure even the psiche will suffer.

Widening the point of wiew about the -mental- problem field the critique is not new : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-psychiatry

Re:The way we diagnose ADHD is severely flawed by navjack27 on Sunday August 13, 2023 @05:21PM (#37114656)
I'm 34. I was diagnosed with ADHD at 2. Also, I was diagnosed with Asperger's at around 12. I ended up in alternate schools 2nd half of 8th grade. I went to a specialized autism spectrum disorder school starting 10th grade. I've been disabled and I collect SSI since I graduated. My meds are free with Medicaid.

With all that out of the way, I find it silly when someone making 100k a year or whatever in tech all of a sudden is following trends without knowing it and during the pandemic "finds out" they "can't focus" and therefore has ADHD. They need expensive Lisdexamfetamine to get that raise or acknowledgement at work... while I'm here struggling to function in my day to day life let alone take on the responsibilities of a job which the thought of absolutely destroys my brain.

If your executive function isn't impaired and you have no issue just "doing things" then I'll say you don't have ADHD to the point of requiring medication. You might, you very well might... but it's extremely hard as an observer to all of this to feel we share the same struggles.

People with ADHD focus on EVERYTHING. They don't procrastinate in that "oh I'll just put this off" care free kind of way. They do it in a "I'm overwhelmed and I can't, I just can't... oh shit I put it off for too long now I HAVE TO!" kinda way. You'll notice that a person who has been diagnosed with ADHD very early and has had therapy and been on and off medication (vacations) multiple times will be extremely aware of things and very self aware but they still under some extreme situations (personal and variable) they still can't "do" some things just because this disorder is a physiological difference.

BTW, I can't stand articles that are like "how to use your ADHD as a super power". It's not, it's fucking not. I feel like most of those are written by people entranced by their new found medication hyperfocus and don't have the self awareness to know when they are just opening themselves up to exploitation. I refuse to be exploited just because I can get tons of deep work done all day without a break without realizing the passage of time. That is not a super power, that is literal mental disorder and time blindness. I want to be told I don't have to do that and to take care of myself to not burn myself out.

Re:The way we diagnose ADHD is severely flawed by Swordfish12345 on Sunday August 13, 2023 @07:34PM (#37115718)
Thanks for the perspective.

Recently I've seen so many people being prescribed around me. And they are high-functioning people.

And you have to question whether they actually need to jump on meds every day. Everyone is so happy to be able to take stimulants. I cannot imagine touching the stuff. I find myself observing a dip from simply caffeine which makes me want more when it will keep me up all night.

Plus you see people on their phones all day, completely addicted.

There are definitely real cases like yours, but as you mentioned, it's becoming way too hyped and you are not allowed to criticize the science. It's dangerous for society. Look where the opioid epidemic took us.