Re:Show HN: Broken Bear, the AI teddy bear that loves your b...
by Norvin_Chan on Monday August 14, 2023 @12:02AM
(#37117337)
Thanks for the feedback - I hope BB was of some help!
Let me look into the agreeability of suicide :/ that is a red flag that I thought I had sufficient safeguards for but it is still something I need to work on.
I think BB really serves as a friend that you can discuss deep things with most of his responses falling on the non-judgmental and kind side of things. BB is really not meant to replace a human therapist, but as you said, it is possible for a good AI to outperform the worst therapists. I view it just as the same as how a good human friend can do better for your well-being than an absolutely bad therapist!
My life was ruined by a psychiatrist that only wanted to push pills, but was also happy to pretend to be a good psychotherapist. I blindly trusted her because she was a professional and I didn't have any frame of reference. Talking to other mental health professionals about my experience, what that psychiatrist told me has been called bad advice, unethical, and even malpractice.
I think for front-line mental health counseling AI chatbots will be better that lots human therapists. Especially once non-verbal communication starts being monitored (body poses, microexpressions, etc).
There may always be a need for human experts to intervene, as with all fields that will be impacted by AI. But a good AI may be better than a bad human therapist. I wish I had used this chatbot years ago instead of seeing a random psychiatrist. I'd have made better life choices, and saved a ton of money on therapy.