Re:Pijul: Version-Control Post-Git • Goto 2023
by saghm on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:44PM
(#37096823)
I was actually looking into libpijul earlier this week, but unfortunately it seems like it's still suffering from some growing pains in terms of friendliness to external devs; after spending over a half an hour delving into the API docs, I couldn't even figure out where the "entrypoint" was, much less how to use the large number of pieces that interacted with each other.
From looking at the implementation of the executable, I think the library could really use some higher-level constructions like `Repository` here[0], or at least some higher-level prose docs explaining how to put the pieces together manually, maybe with a disclaimer like ripgrep's backing library[1] has.
I really like what Pijul is doing from a design standpoint, but unfortunately it's far from the level of polish I would want to be able to consider it as a realistic alternative to git. If I'm going to have to put in effort to work around warts either way, I'm going to pick the tool with warts that I already know how to work around over the one where I'd have to learn from scratch and wouldn't have nearly as many resources to help me learn them.
From looking at the implementation of the executable, I think the library could really use some higher-level constructions like `Repository` here[0], or at least some higher-level prose docs explaining how to put the pieces together manually, maybe with a disclaimer like ripgrep's backing library[1] has.
I really like what Pijul is doing from a design standpoint, but unfortunately it's far from the level of polish I would want to be able to consider it as a realistic alternative to git. If I'm going to have to put in effort to work around warts either way, I'm going to pick the tool with warts that I already know how to work around over the one where I'd have to learn from scratch and wouldn't have nearly as many resources to help me learn them.
[0]: Not sure how to link to a specific line on the Pijul hosting site, but it's in https://nest.pijul.com/pijul/pijul:main/SXEYMYF7P4RZM.W5JQA