Re:YouTube-Dl Site Goes Offline as Hosting Provider Enforces...
by qingcharles on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:29PM
(#37096735)
That's fascinating, thank you. I've been involved with criminal law for a decade and not seen a law like that. I wonder if the accusation has to be made to a law enforcement agency, or whether it would apply in my situation where the person made an accusation to a private entity?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:YouTube-Dl Site Goes Offline as Hosting Provider Enforces...
by skissane on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:51AM
(#37098599)
> I wonder if the accusation has to be made to a law enforcement agency, or whether it would apply in my situation where the person made an accusation to a private entity?
I can't find any case law which directly answers your question; as far as I am aware, no case has ever been prosecuted under that law for the type of scenario we are talking about (but just because it hasn't happened yet, isn't in itself a bar for it happening some day in the future). This law never says the false accusation has to be made to a law enforcement agency, even though similar laws in other jurisdictions do explicitly say that; I don't see why a court would insert that requirement when the text doesn't explicitly contain it. But of course, nobody can be certain unless some day the matter actually comes before a court to decide.