News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Game Theory Explained: Why The Joker and Not Batman is Ou... by kstenerud on Thursday March 15, 2012 @01:11PM (#3709368)
One big problem I see here is a tendency for black & white thinking. People in the real world don't fit into a neat little "cooperator" or "defector" package. A person's tendency to cooperate can be dependent upon a huge number of factors, including what the subject of cooperation is, how they're feeling that day, current events, political, moral, and religious opinions in vogue, illness and injury, the size of the potential benefit, relationships to other people who may be defecting or cooperating, whether they are a leader or a follower, etc.

Running a simulation of simple, unchanging people doesn't produce much useful information for the real world. Real life cooperation relationships are a lot more intricate and complex.

Re:Game Theory Explained: Why The Joker and Not Batman is Ou... by fragsworth on Thursday March 15, 2012 @01:44PM (#3709566)
Your complaints are not really a huge problems with this statistical population model. In the end, you took goods out of a system and/or you put goods back into it - everyone falls somewhere along this scale in their lifetimes. All the reasons behind their choices are largely irrelevant, and you can simulate the model based on it.
Re:Game Theory Explained: Why The Joker and Not Batman is Ou... by stinkytaco on Thursday March 15, 2012 @02:05PM (#3709714)
You can sometimes emulate the model, but not always. See the other post in this thread about post 9/11 America.

The problem is that a few well positioned people who behave in a way that is not predictable, or larger forces that the model cannot anticipate (socio-economic, the weather, etc.) can distrupt the model.

Not that the model doesn't 1. Do a good job of explaining a concept and 2. Possibly fits into a larger, more complex model.