So who are the jokers in this picture? The socially excluded psychopaths and sociopaths who sit in prison. I think that the proportion of real jokers (completely destructive agents) is extremely small and their effect is vastly overstated. I think that in real life, significant jokers tend to be forces of nature like hurricanes and tsunamis, not people.
And actually, as katovatzschyn kind of points out, this setup (citizens / military-industrial complex / terrorists) may not actually map very well at all to the cooperator / defector / joker model.
Also, defectors want the maximum gain for least effort, so can reasonably decide to act as cooperators for the minimum time required to keep their preferred level of sloth going.
Jokers could also decide, if they trusted this model, that to increase overall destruction they act always as defectors, as otherwise they are just ushering in a new round of cooperation.
Jokers achieve greatest absolute destruction when the lifetime of the system is indefinite--you have to have sand castles before you can kick them over. So, it would seem to me that they'd be more likely to become cooperators for the sole purpose of building things back up to burn them down again.
Loki: likes eternal chaos, so fits your model.
Ice Giants: likes Ragnarök, so only sleeps or destroys.
However, both Loki and the Ice Giants could conceivably decide to act as cooperators if they suspect that there are a large number of defectors who are currently acting as cooperators, with the aim of overwhelming the cooperators by switching back to being jokers when the other fake cooperators switch back to being defectors.
[edit] Also, 'Loki and the Ice Giants' would make a really good band name, or possibly a tumblr site (nod to the xkcd enthusiasts).
Hm....
Ice Giants would seem to suggest a fourth state, one of pure inactivity.
I would almost say that you could model these modes (as the paper does) by changing the damage value to be 0 (dormant, effectively, Ice Giants) for some chosen system conditions. Were you to assign a negative damage, you might be able to model jokers-as-cooperator.
The interesting (perhaps most interesting) thing about the Jokers is that they have no stake in the system. So, I wonder how to account/model that in a Jokers-can-become-Coopearators system. Hm.
Somewhat thankfully, true destroy-all-the-things thinking writ large and competently executed seems to be a very rare thing in the species.
I can't pin my finger on what makes post-9/11 US different. Were the jokers not destructive enough? Does the model not account for power structure, or psychological needs (i.e. security) and exploitation thereof? Is the effect of a single joker short-lived (which would correspond to the outpouring of national unity post-9/11)? Did the 9/11 attacks actually increase the cooperator/defector ratio in the long term in a way that is not apparent to me?