Re:LK-99: Phonon Bands, Localized Flat Band Magnetism, Model...
by imtringued on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:47AM
(#37062570)
>Currently this guy is practically using his real name, with his university and professor exposed. It takes some courage to lie at this point.
No, it doesn't. It is a nine second video. Not a research paper. Right now the topic is being hyped up and you might care but next year nobody is going to give a damn about some random video uploaded to bilibili.
Why does everyone on HN pretend that even the smallest of missteps is going to end a reserachers career and therefore even videos with almost no effort put into them, that to feed the rumor mills, are somehow the paragon of truth?
Re:LK-99: Phonon Bands, Localized Flat Band Magnetism, Model...
by vinnyvichy on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:43AM
(#37063458)
There's a third interpretation: he took an x-ray of both bits of the sample and found that the XRD pattern of the levitating flake didn't match LK99's
So, some other material levitating itself in seemingly room temperature?
Currently this guy is practically using his real name, with his university and professor exposed. It takes some courage to lie at this point.
link(in Chinese): https://bilibili.com/video/BV1Zh4y1r7XL
======================
Edit: People sometimes speak in convoluted ways. I feel "The sample was not LK99" could have two interpretations here: 1. It is a completely different compound. 2. It is a derivative from LK99 with a different synthesis/doping method.