News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overworked and Underpaid, VFX Workers Vote to Unionize at... by ClimaxGravely on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:36PM (#37042958)
I'm not well versed in the business side of things so I want to ask : Isn't fixed cost contracts considered usually a bad idea in creative-technical endeavors?

I spent about 10 years or so working in AAA games and I found that I had to work in a way that was essentially anticipating major changes. Essentially a totally different approach to programming compared to the other programming jobs I've had (robotics/finance/academic).

Many games I've worked on, the shipped product is completely different from the initial prototype that was sold.

My understanding was generally you get into a contract with a publisher and have a payment schedule every N months. At each checkpoint the publisher can assess whether they want to continue with the contract or let it go.

I can't imagine this kind of project ever working with a fixed-cost contract. Extreme change is the norm when you have creatives at the helm of the project.

Re:Overworked and Underpaid, VFX Workers Vote to Unionize at... by LapsangGuzzler on Monday August 07, 2023 @09:50PM (#37043469)
> Isn't fixed cost contracts considered usually a bad idea in creative-technical endeavors?

Yes, but Marvel is one of the largest (if not the largest) buyers of VFX work in Hollywood and is known for keeping a list of studios they will and won’t work with, which gives them favorable terms with the VFX houses.

Re:Overworked and Underpaid, VFX Workers Vote to Unionize at... by rperez333 on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @12:07AM (#37044414)
Scott Ross, founder and former CEO of Digital Domain, spoke for years about this. The issue is there are just a handful of film studios capable of keeping a large VFX facility busy, so they have a lot of leverage when negotiating contracts and setting prices.

Because that part of the film process can run offshore, VFX studios find themselves fighting for these contracts and/or accepting unadvantegeous terms. I remember him saying that film studios can strong arm a VFX facility to open in a place under heavy tax breaks, and they are expected to 'forward' the cost savings.

https://vimeo.com/66487005

Re:Overworked and Underpaid, VFX Workers Vote to Unionize at... by ClimaxGravely on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @02:28AM (#37045240)
Thanks for the info. That sounds like quite a rough situation. I guess games aren't really an analog despite being one of those creative/technical industries.
Re:Overworked and Underpaid, VFX Workers Vote to Unionize at... by P_I_Staker on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @09:14AM (#37048489)
I don't think it's a problem if the requirements are clear, the artist knows how much a work like it takes, and it's understood that it will be delivered as is; there might be some room for input from the customer, and some rework negotiated in, but you're not putting in unexpected new work.

The scope doesn't change. When a product has been completed, with all negotiated re-work, the final bill is due, or you pay for more work. Intellectual property transfers after final payment. It doesn't have to be this hard.