News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by A_D_E_P_T on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:16AM (#37032516)
LK-99 is a quasi two-dimensional material, and one which seems particularly challenging to synthesize in a bulk polycrystalline three-dimensional mass. Even the original researchers stated that they'd "get it right" only a fraction of the time, and that their famous floating cracked-disc is still impure.

I think that there's no reason to assume that negative results right now are conclusive, whereas positive results are strongly indicative.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by ThePhysicist on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:28AM (#37032601)
It's a hexagonal lead-apatite crystal, how is that "quasi two-dimensional"?
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by jstanley on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:35AM (#37032642)
I don't know anything about lead-apatite crystals, but I know that hexagons are 2-dimensional.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by kergonath on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:46AM (#37032732)
Hexagonal refers to the type of crystal lattice. Most hexagonal crystals, including apatites, have a 3-dimensional structure.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by A_D_E_P_T on Monday August 07, 2023 @07:24AM (#37032996)
Even lead apatite is anisotropic. It conducts electrons along a plane from lead atom to lead atom --- where the phosporous atoms are insulators.

Superconductivity in LK-99 moves along a similarly anisotropic two-dimensional plane.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by ThePhysicist on Monday August 07, 2023 @09:51AM (#37034452)
Do you have a reference for that claim?
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by kergonath on Monday August 07, 2023 @06:49AM (#37032750)
> LK-99 is a quasi two-dimensional material

There is nothing 2-dimensional about the Apatite structure, and the preprints I have seen do not show any kind of “quasi two-dimensional” structure. If anything, it’s more like an array of tubes and chains, more 1D than 2D. Do you have a source making this claim?

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by cubefox on Monday August 07, 2023 @07:39AM (#37033101)
1D would arguably make it even more challenging to synthesize than 2D.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by kergonath on Monday August 07, 2023 @07:42AM (#37033123)
Not really. It’s more of a matter of chemistry and bonding than the dimensionality of the structure.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by cubefox on Monday August 07, 2023 @02:04PM (#37038201)
I think the lower the dimensionality, the harder it is to align pieces. For 3D material you could probably just grind your impure sample down into a powder, isolate the grains that levitate, and press them back together. That wouldn't preserve structures in 2D though, let alone 1D.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by kergonath on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @04:36PM (#37055126)
> I think the lower the dimensionality, the harder it is to align pieces.

First, you’re not talking about synthesis anymore. And if you try to grow a single crystal, how easy it is to get polycrystals from powder is not really relevant. Ease to synthesise and ease to assemble are very different things and both are controlled by different phenomena.

Also, again, not really. Graphene is quasi 2-dimensional and very easy to bunch up and form graphite, for example. Boron nitride, not that much.

> For 3D material you could probably just grind your impure sample down into a powder, isolate the grains that levitate, and press them back together.

You can do something like that (hot or cold pressing), but it still requires the right material to be synthesised in the first place. It works more or less well depending on chemistry and physical properties, not dimensionality.

Separating “grains that work” and “grains that don’t” is not something we really do when we create materials. It sounds more like QA in semiconductors than something we’d do in a lab.

> That wouldn't preserve structures in 2D though, let alone 1D.

Why not? If you grind a 2-D structure joint you just get flat grains. How well they assemble depends on their properties.

The whole discussion is not very productive: however truthy it sounds, dimensionality does not control how easy it is to synthesise a material. Apatites are very easy to make. Things like chalcogenide glasses are easy to make despite having a 1-dimensional structure at the atomic scale. There are many other examples. And, also again: it does not matter because apatites are fully 3-d structures, with linear elements if you squint and ignore how these elements are placed in the overall structure.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by throwaway4PP on Thursday August 10, 2023 @10:27PM (#37084380)
there it is! enough arm-chair theorizing by computer "scientists", an actual material scientists! or condensed matter physicist, or crystallographic expert, or inorganic chemist...
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by samwillis on Monday August 07, 2023 @07:00AM (#37032829)
> seems particularly challenging to synthesize

My reading of the situation was that they have been making this stuff for quite a while (years!), but haven't had the funding or manufacturing expertise to start scaling up and properly improving the process. They are a tiny research lab. The suggestion seems to be that one newer (now former) member of the lab just thought F-this we need to publish, get it out there and start moving forward.

If it is real, the level of investment in finding ways to make this stuff is going to explode. It may be hard to make, but that won't stop us from finding a way to make it on a large scale if it truly is revolutionary.

Further to that, from other groups studying it we will potentially find better and easer to make alternatives.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by N-Krause on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:18AM (#37033407)
Where did you get that "(years!)" from? Is it just a conclusion you came to or are those actual facts. If so, I would love to see a source or a direction to where to look for it.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by samwillis on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:25AM (#37033467)
They first submitted a (rejected) paper to Nature about LK-99 in 2020, 3 years ago - that we know.

The 99 in the name comes from the date the lab was formed, 1999. Some sources suggest that they have been studying this exact material since 1999, although I don't think that is confirmed.

I think it's safe to assume that they would have been making it for at least 1-2 years before the rejected Nature paper, although potentially significantly longer than that.

So they have been making it somewhere between 4 and 24 years...

Looking at how small the fragments are that other lambs are creating, I assume it's taken them years to get to the point that they can make larger lumps of the stuff that have any sort of uniform structure.

They seem to have been trying to perfect it before publishing.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by n2d4 on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:41AM (#37033612)
According to Wikipedia [1], Q Centre was founded in 2008. LK-99 is called LK-99 because it was discovered in 1999.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LK-99#Compound_name

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by samwillis on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:46AM (#37033655)
Ah, my mistake. A 1999 discovery while plausible seems like a long time ago. I wander if it really is exactly the compound as they found back then.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by neom on Monday August 07, 2023 @09:25AM (#37034126)
The Korean press seems to indicate that's when their mentor professor passed away and asked them to continue research on a theory he had, they've been slogging away on it since.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by s1artibartfast on Monday August 07, 2023 @11:27AM (#37035791)
I dont think it was a mere request. They also left money in their will to support further research from what I read.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by viscanti on Monday August 07, 2023 @09:28AM (#37034168)
It wasn't discovered in 99. That's when two of the researchers were in university and had a professor who had a theory that something like it could work. They took a good amount of time off from it while they worked at other jobs, before starting at their research center.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by n2d4 on Monday August 07, 2023 @09:42AM (#37034340)
From the NYT source linked on the Wikipedia article:

> The name of the material comes from the initials of the surnames of two of the scientists — Sukbae Lee and Ji-Hoon Kim — and the year 1999, when they say they first synthesized LK-99.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/03/science/lk-99-superconduc...

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by viscanti on Monday August 07, 2023 @12:59PM (#37037210)
I guess it depends what you mean by LK-99. They didn't have any luck with their early batches and it wasn't until after an extended break in adjunct professorship and industry that they got back together. A happy accident happened where they bumped it part way through trying to synthesize it and they got a sample with some of the properties that kept them going. So in 99, they were just following the advice of their mentor who was a professor. The NYT coverage is misleading in that they weren't really sitting on room temperature and pressure superconductors for 20+ years.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by vel0city on Monday August 07, 2023 @11:05AM (#37035483)
Even then, them synthesizing some of it in '99 and then again in '22 or whenever doesn't really mean they've been making it for 23 years.

If I baked a cake once 23 years ago and once yesterday, I can't really say I've been baking for 23 years.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by gitfan86 on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:35AM (#37033562)
It is like playing the lottery or slot machine. You just keep trying one more time to see if you can hit the jackpot.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by conception on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:25AM (#37033465)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LK-99

It’s called LK-99 as it was discovered in 1999.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by fallingknife on Monday August 07, 2023 @08:23AM (#37033444)
The 99 in lk99 means 1999
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by jiggawatts on Monday August 07, 2023 @04:54PM (#37040811)
> quite a while (years!)

Katalin Karikó was working on mRNA vaccine technology for decades on a relatively tiny budget, and was turned down by many larger groups based on the supposed impossibility of the concept.

You have to wonder how many future technologies are languishing right now in some basement lab where a couple of frustrated scientists are making do with a shoestring budget and are desperate to get their research published.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by marcosdumay on Monday August 07, 2023 @09:25AM (#37034133)
I'd say that positive results are only strongly indicative if they contain some property that absolutely can not be explained any other way (like the full levitation of that badly sourced video that we can't be sure abut the veracity) or if they are numerous enough to rule out rare effects.

Outside of that, positive results only weakly imply LK-99 is real.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by fguerraz on Monday August 07, 2023 @09:34AM (#37034250)
I have my I WANT TO BELIEVE poster ready
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by jona-f on Monday August 07, 2023 @10:37AM (#37035047)
Doesnt LK-99 crystallize in the perovskite structure? That's very 3D. I think cuprate superconductors do too, but I'm guessing, cause it's a long time I was into that sort of thing. What do you mean by "quasi two-dimensional". Every crystal has 2d planes (apart from rare penrose-style quasicrystals) and many crystals are anisotropic. People don't call these "quasi two-dimensional" afaik.
Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by Qwertious on Monday August 07, 2023 @11:10AM (#37035556)
>LK-99 is a quasi two-dimensional material,

Hey, what does this actually mean? Like, space is 3D and I don't think you're claiming all LK99 samples are all literally-one-atom-thick, so clearly it's a 3D object.

I'd guess it means that the material has very regular layers, but (much like graphene) I've never actually seen someone directly say what "two-dimensional material" means 3-dimensionally.

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by DiscoBahb on Monday August 07, 2023 @11:53AM (#37036140)
Think of it this way: in something like copper, atoms are arranged in a 3d lattice, and electrons are able to jump (or "tunnel") from copper atom to copper atom freely in any of the x, y or z directions because the lattice looks the same in each direction.

Some more complex materials do not have this symmetry, and the ability of the electrons to tunnel is much stronger in some directions than others. In many known high temperature superconductors electrons are more or less confined to move in a 2d plane (even though a lump of the material is obviously a 3d object) so they are called "quasi-2d".

In other materials they are confined to move in only one direction, which seems to be the case with LK-99

Re:Ongoing compilation table of LK-99 reproduction claims by lost_tourist on Monday August 07, 2023 @01:05PM (#37037293)
"...whereas positive results are strongly indicative..." [if the claims come from highly respected labs with experienced experimental scientists]