News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by satvikpendem on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:36PM (#37026385)
The personal freedom to fly through your windshield, indeed.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by mcculley on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:42PM (#37026465)
It baffles me that motorcycles are legal in jurisdictions that require seat belts in cars.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by chrisco255 on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:58PM (#37026673)
Well this demonstrates the cognitive dissonance of our modern political system. On the one hand we have to accept that motorcycles are both inherently very deadly and accept the legality of their use. Not only that but in most jurisdictions it's legal to ride without a helmet. On the other hand, seat belt fines are perfectly acceptable and only anarchist weirdos would be opposed to them. We also have to be mad at cops for stopping people and questioning them, event though that is the only way to enforce seat belt laws.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by runarberg on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:38PM (#37027089)
I think the US is kind of unique when it comes to motorcycle safety laws (or rather the lack of them) and still 18 states + DC require helmets for all riders. Most states have some age requirements, and only three states have no helmet laws for motorcycles.

Every country in Europe requires a helmet, so does Canada and Mexico.

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by consumer451 on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:54PM (#37026632)
I can't tell if this is a serious comment or not.

If it is genuine, did you mean motorcycles without helmet enforcement?

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by mcculley on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:38PM (#37027093)
I am seriously baffled.

I live in Florida, where motorcyclists are allowed to go unhelmeted while car drivers are required to wear seat belts.

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by consumer451 on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:40PM (#37027107)
> Donorcycles: Motorcycle Helmet Laws and the Supply of Organ Donors

https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/661256

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by figassis on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:51PM (#37026587)
It’s probably more dangerous for you not to ditch your bike than it is to stay on it when collision is eminent? I can’t confirm this though, but most times I’ve seen an experienced person fall off a bike, they don’t stay on it.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by mcculley on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:40PM (#37027110)
I think riding a motorcycle is accepting an enormous amount of risk. I don't see why we should permit that for some and limit it for others.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by jandrese on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:04PM (#37026743)
Motorcycles are kinda grandfathered in at this point. If they were invented today they would never be allowed on the road.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by IshKebab on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:01PM (#37026709)
Why? Safety isn't generally about achieving an absolute probability of death. Does it baffle you that human space flight exists in a country that requires wet floor signs?
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by mcculley on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:35PM (#37027062)
The spaceflight/floor example does not baffle me at all. It is my responsibility to put up a wet floor sign to keep from harming others. When I am walking near a wet floor, I expect the owner of the floor to limit risk and liability for me and others walking on the floor.

While I always wear a seat belt and will not even move my car without ensuring that my passengers are wearing their seat belts, I don't feel I should tell other drivers what to do inside their cars.

I live in Florida, where motorcycle riders are not required to wear helmets while those riding in cars are required to wear seat belts. It is silly.

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by IshKebab on Monday August 07, 2023 @02:46AM (#37031048)
Yeah the helmets thing is very silly. Think about car insurance though.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by runarberg on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:56PM (#37026648)
Most jurisdictions require motorcycle riders to wear pretty through safety gear, such as a helmet and protective clothing.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by mcculley on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:31PM (#37027029)
I live in Florida, where motorcycle riders are not required to wear helmets while those riding in cars are required to wear seat belts.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by runarberg on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:40PM (#37027120)
* * *
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by mcculley on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:56PM (#37027282)
Motorcycle safety gear is great for keeping the corpse in one package. I don’t see how it does anything to keep the rider from being ejected from the vehicle. It baffles me that we are very paternal about drivers of cars and allow motorcycle riders on the same roads.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by runarberg on Sunday August 06, 2023 @08:07PM (#37028335)
You know this isn’t true. They do tests on this gear (particularly the helmets), and they are required to pass a number of these tests and fulfill a certain standard. If this gear provided no additional safety, then these tests would show it.

This is unless you believe the tests don’t really reflect reality, but then you are objecting science accepted by several regulatory bodies. You’ll have to give me more evidence than your word against decades of experiments and expert opinions.

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by mcculley on Monday August 07, 2023 @07:25AM (#37033006)
I never claimed that safety gear provided no additional safety.

Another commenter pointed out that unhelmeted motorcyclists contribute to the supply of organs (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37027107), so I think it all works out.

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by runarberg on Monday August 07, 2023 @11:46AM (#37036040)
> unhelmeted motorcyclists contribute to the supply of organs

I don’t get the impression that neither the commenter, nor the paper cited, thinks this is a good thing.

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by mcculley on Monday August 07, 2023 @02:21PM (#37038460)
Neither did I get that impression. I was speaking only for myself. Maybe the inconsistency in the law is good from a utilitarian point of view.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by runarberg on Monday August 07, 2023 @05:04PM (#37040937)
I could be wrong, but it sounds like you are implying that the organs of some people are worth more than the lives the same same people.

Regardless, the discussion has come a long way from:

Motorcycles should be banned if seatbelts are enforced

→ But motorcycles have safety laws as well to protect the rider

→ Not where I live

→ But in other places they do

→ Well I’ll imply—but not state—that those safety rules don’t protect the riders

→ But the safety gear does* protect riders*

→ And then something about organ harvesting of accidents.

This is a silly debate. You’ve convinced me of nothing, you had a point there somewhere, but it got lost in irrelevance. Both motorcycle riders and automobile drivers have safety gear for their own self preservation which they are required to use in most places. Yes there are exceptions to this (such as Florida; or riders of scooters/light motorcycles) but also to cars (New Hampshire does not have seat belt requirements to 17+; neither do many states in India; Bus riders don’t have to wear seat belts in many places; tractors don’t require seat belts; etc.)

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by mcculley on Monday August 07, 2023 @05:42PM (#37041364)
I remain baffled at the silliness. I am not trying to convince you of anything.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday August 06, 2023 @07:35PM (#37028095)
I was surprised it was just 16 states, and Hawaii wasn't one of those. TIL, I guess.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by runarberg on Sunday August 06, 2023 @08:06PM (#37028330)
Sorry, *16 additional states. The total is 19 (including DC).

29 have some age restrictions, where people under a certain age must wear helmets while riding, and only 3 have no laws requiring riders to wear helmets. I think Puerto Rico has a pretty strict helmet wearing law since 2007[1]. I haven’t found any data about the other territories.

1: https://www.nhtsa.gov/sites/nhtsa.gov/files/documents/812397...

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by kneebonian on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:37PM (#37026402)
The whole point of this country is if you want to eat garbage, balloon up to 600 pounds and die of a heart attack at 43, you can! You are free to do so. To me, that's beautiful. - Ron Swanson
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by stouset on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:39PM (#37026434)
And then we came to the collective realization that—while great in theory—letting people unintentionally suicide themselves through carelessness and neglect imposes costs borne by the rest of society.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by seanp2k2 on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:43PM (#37026471)
Then COVID happened and we un-came to that realization, especially when one person’s decision affected others in a very direct and deadly way.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by nemo44x on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:43PM (#37026475)
What about people that make healthy choices and live long enough to bear cancer a few times, shake off a few other diseases, have hips replaced, collect endless Medicare and SS payments, etc?

The person who blows their heart out at 53 probably costs a whole lot less VS what they put into society.

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by jdiff on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:03PM (#37026739)
Sure, your weird struck-by-lightning-57-times strawman might cost more than your average suicide-by-mcdonalds person. But healthy people are more productive and are productive for longer and only a vanishingly small portion of them are ever going to get struck by lightning once, let alone 57 times.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by nemo44x on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:14PM (#37026853)
People use the vast majority of their lives medical expenditure in their last year or so of life if they make it to old age. Someone dying in their 50s before they hit the ground coats very little. Saying that I hope everyone lives long healthy lives.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by jdiff on Sunday August 06, 2023 @06:07PM (#37027387)
They're not vanishing silently and peacefully into the night, they're killing themselves with chronic poor health. That's the entire problem, they're not dodging it, they're embracing, amplifying, and accelerating it.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by brightlancer on Sunday August 06, 2023 @06:53PM (#37027779)
> But healthy people are more productive and are productive for longer

Not nearly as long as they live, sucking up healthcare resources.

"Unhealthy" people like smokers and the obese are more cost-effective, because they're nearly as productive per year and they die before needing the absurdly expensive medical care for old age.

https://web.archive.org/web/20230728192509/https://www.nytim...

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by pengaru on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:43PM (#37026478)
The primary effect of seatbelt laws is fundraising through pointless fines.

And some informed folks have even argued that in modern vehicles airbags are so effective seatbelts could be worsening accident outcomes. (Elon Musk made this point in one of his podcast appearances re: Teslas)

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by CJefferson on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:49PM (#37026558)
Which informed folks? Can you provide any study about this, because I haven't heard of any.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by pengaru on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:55PM (#37026645)
Are you suggesting Elon Musk lied to us in JRE #1609?
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by callalex on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:30PM (#37027018)
Yes. In fact he lies on most days that end in y.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by runarberg on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:19PM (#37026895)
If he made this point there, then yes, yes he lied. This is a lie.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by owenmarshall on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:54PM (#37026634)
This is 2023’s version of saying “no, actually, it’s safer to be thrown clear if you’re in a wreck so you don’t end up trapped in a burning car.”
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by sobkas on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:02PM (#37026720)
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by pengaru on Sunday August 06, 2023 @11:44PM (#37029822)
Presumably air bags have improved in the 15 years since then...
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by Arrath on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:52PM (#37026602)
Having been in a roll over accident, yes air bags saved me from braining myself on the door window (I quite appreciate that side curtain airbag now) but would have done sweet fuck all for keeping me actually in my seat during the events.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by runarberg on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:51PM (#37026591)
Pointless conjuncture.

If you want to make this argument, you can at least provide some data on how much some police departments make by collecting seat belt fines, and compare it to other fines and cost of operation. I doubt the seat belt fines are significant enough to warrant this speculation.

The airbag argument is even worse. Modern vehicles go through numerous safety standard tests, including real world experiments where test dummies are put in an actual car crash. If seat belts make the crash worse for the dummy than airbag alone, these tests would have shown it, and there would be publications about it in a peer reviewed science journal. If you are so confident, you should be able to find at least one such publication. I doubt you will.

Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by stonogo on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:56PM (#37026653)
How on earth can you possibly consider Elon Musk "informed"
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by bordercases on Monday August 07, 2023 @01:08AM (#37030389)
Contrarians arguing the possibility without evidence yet cited to back it up is not a definitive conclusion, let alone informed.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by eikenberry on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:48PM (#37026547)
The problem isn't that people don't realize the behavioral issue here, it is that "we" can't decide on out to best mitigate the costs. People don't really seem able to address this as absolutists keep dominating the discussions not allowing any progress as that invariably requires compromises they are unwilling to make.
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by DANmode on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:53PM (#37026617)
No implied value whatsoever in Darwinism anymore, or what's the story?
Re:When seat belt laws drew fire as a violation of personal ... by consumer451 on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:28PM (#37026998)
"Greed is good" - Gordon Gekko