Re:Replace Peer Review with “Peer Replication” (2021)
by harimau777 on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:05PM
(#37026043)
I think that there's also a lot of psychological/cultural/political issues that work also need to be worked out:
If someone wins the Nobel Prize, do the people who replicated their work also win it? When the history books are written do the replicators get equal billing to the people who made the discovery?
When selecting candidates for prestigious positions, are they really going to consider a replicator equal to an original researcher?
If someone wins the Nobel Prize, do the people who replicated their work also win it? When the history books are written do the replicators get equal billing to the people who made the discovery?
When selecting candidates for prestigious positions, are they really going to consider a replicator equal to an original researcher?