According to Facebook's S1 filings, their expenses correspond to roughly $1 per user per year, and their revenue is $4 per user per year.
I would pay > $4 per year if it meant I controlled my Facebook data (i.e., I was the customer, not the product).
I would absolutely be willing to pay $24 a year for what Google offers for free if the alternatives were what existed before those services got big (i.e. altavista and hotmail).
Search and spam were both huge time-sinks.
The best estimates I have for what it costs google to provide service to one customer for 1/year is $20 < n < $24 and Facebook is probably more, can you name even one person of your acquaintance who would pay even $12/year for either of those services...? Even if hardly anyone else was using them? Before they were big?
So yeah, impossible, at least in the given constraints; like asking for a 50 seat airplane that's self-piloted, safer than current small planes AND costs less than $500 to build.
You might argue about my definition of impossible, but this isn't reddit, and I hope you recognize and understand that difference.