News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andrew McCalip demonstrates synthesis of LK99 by giantrobot on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:04PM (#37001860)
My personal opinion/reaction likely isn't going to affect anyone's grant status. I'm just a random asshole. But there are less random assholes whose opinion might count. If someone sounding authoritative, but is just a random asshole like me, shits on this work on social media it might affect a group's grant status if it taints the opinion of someone holding the purse strings.

So I don't think asking about credentials or asking about references is gatekeeping. It's putting a statement into context. If I as a random asshole say "this isn't a superconductor" you as a reader should want to know where I'm getting that opinion from rather than just taking my statement at face value.

Re:Andrew McCalip demonstrates synthesis of LK99 by MetaWhirledPeas on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:21PM (#37002127)
I'm not suggesting we give random people credibility: I'm suggesting that when we make potentially-enormous breakthroughs that maybe we shouldn't keep that information to ourselves for decades.